Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nasdaq  >  Alphabet    GOOGL

Mes dernières consult.
Most popular
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector newsTweets

Exclusive: Alphabet's Waymo demanded $1 billion in settlement talks with Uber - sources

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
10/12/2017 | 10:41am CET
FILE PHOTO: The Waymo logo is displayed during the company's unveil of a self-driving Chrysler Pacifica minivan during the North American International Auto Show in Detroit

SAN FRANCISCO(Reuters) - Alphabet Inc's Waymo sought at least $1 billion in damages and a public apology from Uber Technologies Inc as conditions for settling its high-profile trade secret lawsuit against the ride-services company, sources familiar with the proposal told Reuters.

The Waymo self-driving car unit also asked that an independent monitor be appointed to ensure Uber does not use Waymo technology in the future, the sources said.

Uber rejected those terms as non-starters, said the sources, who were not authorized to publicly discuss settlement talks. The precise dollar amount requested by Waymo and the exact time the offer was made could not be learned.

Waymo's tough negotiating stance, which has not been previously reported, reflects the company's confidence in its legal position after months of pretrial victories in a case which may help to determine who emerges in the forefront of the fast-growing field of self-driving cars.

The aggressive settlement demands also suggest that Waymo is not in a hurry to resolve the lawsuit, in part because of its value as a distraction for Uber leadership, said Elizabeth Rowe, a trade secret expert at the University of Florida Levin College of Law.

Waymo recently persuaded a San Francisco federal judge to delay a trial to decide the dispute from October to early December, citing the need to investigate evidence Uber had not disclosed earlier.

No further settlement talks are currently scheduled, the sources said. The judge overseeing the case mandated that the companies enter mediation with a court-appointed magistrate.

Amy Candido, a Waymo attorney, declined to comment on any settlement talks, but said the company's reasons for suing Uber are "pretty clear."

"Waymo had one goal: to stop Uber from using its trade secrets," she said. "That remains its goal."

An Uber spokesperson declined to comment.


Waymo sued Uber in February, claiming that former engineer Anthony Levandowski downloaded more than 14,000 confidential files before leaving to set up a self-driving truck company, called Otto, which Uber acquired soon after.

Uber denied using any of Waymo's trade secrets.

Waymo's lawsuit has been disruptive for Uber. U.S. District Judge William Alsup granted Waymo's request for a pretrial injunction in May, which prohibited Levandowski from working on Lidar, a key sensor technology for self-driving cars that is the crux of the current litigation.

Uber later fired Levandowski, regarded as a visionary in autonomous technology, after he refused to return Waymo documents at the heart of the case. Levandowski has asserted his constitutional right against self-incrimination and declined to answer questions from Waymo lawyers.

Meanwhile, Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick stepped down as chief executive in June after allegations of widespread misconduct at the company became public. Kalanick has since become embroiled in a boardroom fight with fellow Uber investor Benchmark Capital.

Benchmark cited Waymo's allegations of trade secret theft in separate litigation aimed at forcing Kalanick off Uber's board. A Delaware judge put that lawsuit on hold and sent it to private arbitration.

On Sunday Oct. 1, the day before Kalanick was scheduled to give a deposition in the Waymo case, Kalanick's lawyers called Waymo and asked to postpone the deposition, lawyers for both companies said in court last week.

Kalanick's lawyers said he was in the middle of a fight to appoint new board members and was therefore too busy, Waymo attorneys said in court. Waymo refused the request, forcing Kalanick to attend the deposition.


Causing such distractions for a competitor are a clear benefit to Waymo, Rowe said. Uber has hired three law firms to litigate the case and devoted thousands of hours to probe Uber servers for Waymo confidential information.

"I'm counting all those as good reasons to keep the lawsuit going," Rowe said.

Waymo has estimated damages in the case at about $1.9 billion, according to court filings, which Uber disputes. Despite that figure and the big settlement demands, Waymo views winning a permanent injunction against Uber using any Waymo intellectual property as the main priority, another source familiar with the company's thinking said.

Much of the technical evidence in the case has been filed under seal, making it impossible for outside observers to independently assess the strength of each side's arguments. In court last week, Alsup said Uber's product was "dissimilar" from Waymo's.

Even if a jury finds that Uber stole Waymo trade secrets, Uber says in court filings that its engineers have designed around the Waymo technology at issue in the case. If that is true, that would lessen the impact on Uber in the event of a defeat in court.

Waymo is skeptical of Uber's claim, however. In a court filing on Monday, it requested an order forcing Uber to disclose its source code, or underlying software, for its Lidar products.

The Alphabet subsidiary said in the filing that it recently learned that former employees took Waymo source code when they went to work at Uber, "including software related to the 'brains' of the vehicle that determines how the car moves."

(Reporting by Dan Levine; Editing by Jonathan Weber and Bill Rigby)

By Dan Levine

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on ALPHABET
08:47aTIM COOK : Apple's Tim Cook calls for calm heads on China, U.S. trade
07:48aALPHABET : Google Case Spotlights 'Cy Pres' -- WSJ
03/23U.S. lawmakers formally ask Facebook CEO to testify on user data
03/23#DeleteFacebook? Privacy proves hard to protect online
03/23EU plans tougher consumer laws for Facebook, Gmail
03/23Carrefour calls on Google for voice boost in battle with Amazon
03/23China's Tencent loses $51 billion in market value in two days
03/23ALPHABET : Google Privacy Case Risks Disrupting a Key Source of Nonprofit Fundin..
03/22U.S. Music Revenue Rose in 2017 Lifted by Spotify, Other Streaming Services
03/22Self-driving car industry confronts trust issues after Uber crash
More news
News from SeekingAlpha
03/23Best Information Network Wealth-Builder Stocks Now 
03/23WSJ : Google wants publishers to help collect data consent in EU 
03/22Google partners with CSRA; Assistant can now send money 
03/22YouTube bringing Susan Sarandon movie to theaters 
03/225 Cognitive Biases And Heuristics That Impact Trading Decisions 
Financials ($)
Sales 2018 134 B
EBIT 2018 34 179 M
Net income 2018 29 094 M
Finance 2018 95 909 M
Yield 2018 -
P/E ratio 2018 24,81
P/E ratio 2019 21,16
EV / Sales 2018 4,60x
EV / Sales 2019 3,68x
Capitalization 712 B
Duration : Period :
Alphabet Technical Analysis Chart | GOOGL | US02079K3059 | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends ALPHABET
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 45
Average target price 1 273 $
Spread / Average Target 24%
EPS Revisions
Lawrence E. Page Chief Executive Officer & Director
Sergey Mikhaylovich Brin President & Director
John LeRoy Hennessy Chairman
Ruth Porat Chief Financial Officer & Senior Vice President
Eric E. Schmidt Director & Technical Advisor
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
ALPHABET3.85%711 643
BAIDU-1.76%80 106
NAVER CORP--.--%23 848
YANDEX25.65%13 405
SOGOU INC-27.31%3 293