APA Group (ASX:APA) today lodged a Second Supplementary
Bidder's Statement to address a number of serious flaws and
deficiencies in Hastings Diversified Utilities Fund's
Target's Statement and to further highlight why HDF
securityholders should accept APA's offer.
Managing Director Mick McCormack said: "The directors
of Hastings (as the HDF responsible entity) have labelled
APA's offer as undervalued, however have not provided their
own views on HDF's value, nor have they sought the views of
an independent expert to provide a detailed analysis.
"The lack of disclosure raises questions about whether
break fees from the mezzanine debt and the continuing
payment of multi-million dollar performance fees will have
a material impact on HDF's valuation.
Mr McCormack said the mezzanine debt appears to be unusual
in its terms and conditions and, in APA's view, is likely
to include break costs that will have a significant
negative impact on the value of HDF securities. "The
Hastings board has not provided any information to assess
the value impacts of the mezzanine debt on HDF's business.
"HDF securityholders are the ones who will decide on
this takeover offer, and they deserve to be informed by the
Hastings board of important information that affects value.
The Second Supplementary Bidder's Statement notes that
HDF's directors have failed to provide adequate information
about the continuing payment of performance fees to
Hastings Funds Management, who this month were paid $31.5
million in cash by HDF.
Mr McCormack also said that while Hastings had outlined
several potential growth opportunities in its Target's
Statement, no explanation has been provided as to how those
opportunities are achievable, nor has any value been
ascribed to the opportunities other than references to
their potential.
In addition, APA was concerned about the validity of the
financial performance comparisons used in the Target's
Statement. Mr McCormack said: "The directors of
Hastings have adjusted the benchmark indices to suit
themselves, while the reality is HDF securities are trading
below its offer price seven years ago.
Mr McCormack said there were a number of other incorrect or
inadequate statements in the Target's Statement, which are
addressed in APA's Second Supplementary Bidder's Statement.
"HDF securityholders should carefully read the Second
Supplementary Bidder's Statement and urge the Hastings
board to correct these deficiencies.
Since the offer was first announced on 14 December 2011,
APA has continued to demonstrate its consistent delivery of
strategy and robust financing capability. This is covered
in detail in the Second Supplementary Bidder's Statement.
This includes the announcement of two committed expansion
projects on the Goldfields Gas Pipeline and the issuance of
a JPY10billion (A$126m) medium term note at competitive
market rates. This brings the total amount of debt raised
by APA since 30 June 2011 to over $2 billion.
Mr McCormack said: "This performance further
highlights why HDF securityholders should accept APA's
offer.