Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nyse  >  Bank of America    BAC

News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector newsTweets

Bank of America : Judge Orders Bank of America to Redo Settlement in Mortgage Dispute

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
10/05/2017 | 07:32pm CEST
By Katy Stech Ferek 

The bankruptcy judge handling a dispute between Bank of America Corp. and a California couple who were mistakenly foreclosed on refused to approve a settlement that would end their lawsuit on Wednesday.

Judge Christopher Klein ordered both lawyers for the bank and for Renee and Erik Sundquist to renegotiate parts of the agreement that he said would "give me heartburn." He didn't specifically state which parts of the confidential settlement he didn't like.

The settlement would end a dispute between the bank and Sundquists, who have fought since the economic recession to save their home. In a March ruling, Judge Klein called the bank "brazen" and "heartless" in its treatment of the couple.

Lawyers for the Sundquists said in earlier court papers that the settlement would enable them "to end a long personal and legal nightmare that has impacted every facet of their and their sons' lives." The bank threatened to appeal, which could have prolonged the case for years.

"They have a powerful wish to be done with it," Judge Klein said of the Sundquists, who brought their son to court on Wednesday.

Judge Klein agreed to review the new terms of the settlement at an Oct. 18 hearing.

At Wednesday's hearing, Bank of America lawyer Jonathan Hacker described the settlement as a "very substantial amount of money." Lawyers wouldn't state the exact amount of the settlement but implied that it was larger than what the Sundquists would have taken in under the court ruling. The earlier court order called for the bank to pay the couple nearly $6.1 million in damages.

Several consumer advocacy nonprofits and law schools have called for the settlement details to be revealed, calling them a matter of public interest. In earlier court papers, the groups said "there is no indication...what steps, if any, the bank has taken to remediate the systemic failures identified in this court's opinion."

Throughout Wednesday's hearing, Mr. Hacker defended the bank's request for confidentiality, saying that the details would put the bank at a disadvantage when settling similar disputes.

The push for details came from five law schools -- Berkeley, Davis, Irvine, Los Angeles and San Francisco's UC Hastings -- associated with the University of California system as well as to two consumer-advocacy nonprofits, the National Consumer Law Center and the National Consumer Bankruptcy Rights Center.

The law schools and nonprofits got involved with the bankruptcy case after Judge Klein said that most of the roughly $45 million fine against Bank of America should be directed to them. Under the settlement, the groups wouldn't collect any money.

The couple's trouble with the bank traces to March 2009, when they stopped making mortgage payments after Bank of America officials said they wouldn't consider loan modifications for customers who were current on payments. In the following years, their roughly 20 loan-modification requests were "routinely either lost or declared insufficient, or incomplete or stale or in need of resubmission or denied without comprehensible explanation," the judge's ruling said.

The couple filed for bankruptcy in June 2010. Filings halt foreclosure sales, but the judge said the bank still improperly took the home and gave them a three-day eviction notice. The couple moved out, and Ms. Sundquist was hospitalized with stress-related symptoms of a heart attack several weeks later.

Bank of America officials eventually reversed the sale. The couple moved back in several months later and received a $20,000 fine from their homeowner association for dead landscaping, the ruling said.

The ordeal prompted Judge Klein to issue in March what consumer-bankruptcy advocates believe is the largest fine originating from an individual bankruptcy dispute. His excoriating 107-page court opinion, which declared the bank's actions Kafkaesque, included excerpts from Renee Sundquist's journal that documented harassing visits from bank-related officials and Mr. Sundquist's suicide attempt after the couple discussed their frustrations over the house.

In the ruling, Judge Klein said the fine was meant to be large enough that it wouldn't "be laughed off in the boardroom as petty cash or 'chump change.'"

Write to Katy Stech Ferek at [email protected]

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on BANK OF AMERICA
12:53a JUST IN : Gardens man gets 33 months for Palm Springs bank robbery
10/20 BANK OF AMERICA : and school team up to work on Habitat home
10/20 BANK OF AMERICA : San Jose's historic Bank of Italy building draws investment in..
10/20 MASTERCARD : Launches 'Grow Your Biz Contest' to Support Small Businesses Ready ..
10/20 Factbox - Impact on banks from Britain's vote to leave the EU
10/20 Lloyds investor lawsuit over HBOS deal 'fundamentally flawed', court hears
10/20 A MORAL DEBT EDITORIAL : Why Amazon and other tech companies owe a moral debt to..
10/19 BANK OF AMERICA : Patent Issued for Customer Communication Analysis Tool (USPTO ..
10/19 BANK OF AMERICA : ILLINOIS Manufacturing Industry Celebrates Fourth Revolution A..
10/19 MASTERCARD : Launches "Grow Your Biz Contest" to Support Small Businesses Ready ..
More news
News from SeekingAlpha
10/20 Will SPDR Dividend ETF SDY Underperform In 2018?
10/20 Tracking Ken Fisher's Fisher Asset Management Portfolio - Q3 2017 Update
10/19 JPMORGAN CHASE : If I Had To Own Just One Bank Stock...
10/19 BANK OF AMERICA : Best Bank Buy For Next 5 Years
10/18 Not Much Going Right For Wells Fargo Yet
Financials ($)
Sales 2017 89 324 M
EBIT 2017 33 338 M
Net income 2017 19 450 M
Debt 2017 -
Yield 2017 1,44%
P/E ratio 2017 14,95
P/E ratio 2018 12,54
Capi. / Sales 2017 3,21x
Capi. / Sales 2018 3,10x
Capitalization 287 B
Duration : Period :
Bank of America Technical Analysis Chart | BAC | US0605051046 | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends BANK OF AMERICA
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 31
Average target price 27,7 $
Spread / Average Target 2,1%
EPS Revisions
Brian T. Moynihan Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Catherine P. Bessant Co-COO & Chief Technology Officer
Thomas Kell Montag Co-Chief Operating Officer
Paul M. Donofrio Chief Financial Officer
Thomas J. May Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
BANK OF AMERICA19.82%286 659
WELLS FARGO-2.47%263 198
BANK OF CHINA LTD20.35%218 574