No respite for SMEs despite economic recovery

April 16, 2014

Latest Red Flag Alert Report for Q1 2014

  • More than 200,000 SMEs in significant financial distress despite improving economic climate

  • Access to funding remains a major hurdle as economic recovery brings over-trading risks

New research released today by business recovery experts Begbies Traynor shows that small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are being left behind as the UK recovery accelerates, with limited access to funding, the risk of over-trading and increased competition emerging as the biggest drags on growth.

The Q1 2014 Red Flag Alert reveals a 22% increase in the number of small businesses suffering from 'significant' financial distress compared with the equivalent period last year, offering a stark contrast with the fortunes of larger businesses, which enjoyed a 14% decline in distress levels over the same period.

According to the data, SMEs now account for 92%, or 207,505, of the 225,549 UK businesses facing 'significant' financial distress compared to 169,800 at the end of Q1 2013, when SMEs represented 89% of all businesses at 'significant' risk.

Small businesses in consumer facing sectors have fared worst over the twelve month period, with SMEs in the troubled bars and restaurants sector now making up 98% of that industry's struggling businesses; significantly higher than the average of 92% seen across the entire economy today. Meanwhile the number of general retailers in 'significant' financial difficulty rose 16% year on year to 13,130, of which a significant 97% are classified as SMEs.

Julie Palmer, Partner at Begbies Traynor Group, said: "Given current market sentiment, today's news may be a bitter pill to swallow for many, but the fact remains that a growing number of SMEs remain at significant risk of falling into distress and need greater support if they are going to turn their fortunes around."

"In the worst performing industries such as retail, bars and restaurants, which are highly dependent on levels of consumer spending, smaller enterprises are simply unable to compete with the buying power of larger chains and have struggled to match the discounts offered by bigger competitors seeking to maintain market share."

"Larger firms across the economy who have easy access to bank finance and years of experience on their side, have been able to take full advantage of the economic resurgence through measures such as extensive discounting, capacity expansion and increased marketing. However, as the recent Government consultation into SME financing shows, smaller businesses are far too often coming up against a brick wall when trying to secure vital funding for growth."

"As the Red Flag analysis has identified in previous quarters, increasing order intake driven by the rebounding economy actually exacerbates this problem, as businesses run into working capital shortages caused by overtrading. The information gap between the banks and small businesses means that many SMEs are unaware of how to access alternative financing such as peer group lending and venture capital. Unless this is addressed soon we expect this upwards trend in SME distress to continue through 2014."

Significant problems by Sector

Sector

Q1 2013

Q1 2014

Percent change

Q4 2014

Q1 2014

Percent change

Automotive

6,389

7,518

18%

7,491

7,518

0%

Bars & Restaurants

11,470

13,188

15%

12,942

13,188

2%

Construction

12,386

14,337

16%

14,221

14,337

1%

Financial Services

3,885

4,131

6%

4,074

4,131

1%

Food & Bev Mfr

654

728

11%

733

728

-1%

Food Retailing

2,478

2,823

14%

2,878

2,823

-2%

General Retail

11,359

13,130

16%

13,051

13,130

1%

Hotels

2,619

3,280

25%

3,256

3,280

1%

Ind Transport & Logistics

2,110

2,602

23%

2,507

2,602

4%

Leisure

5,185

6,219

20%

6,133

6,219

1%

Media

6,712

8,192

22%

8,154

8,192

0%

Other Mfrg

5,663

6,390

13%

6,347

6,390

1%

Others

19,112

21,952

15%

21,645

21,952

1%

Printing & Packaging

791

891

13%

871

891

2%

Professional Services

13,627

17,047

25%

16,865

17,047

1%

Real Estate

15,394

19,941

30%

19,954

19,941

0%

Sports & Recreation

3,726

4,558

22%

4,533

4,558

1%

Support Services

14,938

17,496

17%

17,592

17,496

-1%

Telecoms & IT

10,430

12,649

21%

12,564

12,649

1%

Travel & Tourism

2,923

3,230

11%

3,215

3,230

0%

Uncoded

35,997

41,902

16%

42,121

41,902

-1%

Utilities

103

116

13%

133

116

-13%

Wholesaling

2,836

3,229

14%

3,299

3,229

-2%

All Sectors

190,787

225,549

18%

224,579

225,549

0%

SME / Large Business Significant problems by sector

Sector

Q1 2013 Large

Q1 2014 Large

Q1 2013 SMEs

Q1 2014 SMEs

Q1 2013

Q1 2014

Percent change

Automotive

5%

4%

95%

96%

6389

7518

18%

Bars & Restaurants

3%

2%

97%

98%

11470

13188

15%

Construction

7%

4%

93%

96%

12386

14337

16%

Financial Services

36%

29%

64%

71%

3885

4131

6%

Food & Bev Mfr

26%

21%

74%

79%

654

728

11%

Food Retailing

6%

5%

94%

95%

2478

2823

14%

General Retail

4%

3%

96%

97%

11359

13130

16%

Hotels

21%

15%

79%

85%

2619

3280

25%

Ind Transport & Logistics

11%

8%

89%

92%

2110

2602

23%

Leisure

10%

7%

90%

93%

5185

6219

20%

Media

10%

7%

90%

93%

6712

8192

22%

Other Mfrg

18%

13%

82%

87%

5663

6390

13%

Others

14%

11%

86%

89%

19112

21952

15%

Printing & Packaging

11%

9%

89%

91%

791

891

13%

Professional Services

4%

3%

96%

97%

13627

17047

25%

Real Estate

14%

9%

86%

91%

15394

19941

30%

Sports & Recreation

11%

8%

89%

92%

3726

4558

22%

Support Services

22%

17%

78%

83%

14938

17496

17%

Telecoms & IT

9%

7%

91%

93%

10430

12649

21%

Travel & Tourism

12%

9%

88%

91%

2923

3230

11%

Uncoded

9%

7%

91%

93%

35997

41902

16%

Utilities

31%

24%

69%

76%

103

116

13%

Wholesaling

18%

14%

82%

86%

2836

3229

14%

All Sectors

11%

8%

89%

92%

190,787

225,549

18%

distributed by