NEW YORK, June 23 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Bion Environmental
Technologies, Inc. (OTC Bulletin Board: BNET) today outlined the capabilities
and performance of its comprehensive livestock environmental treatment
technology compared to anaerobic digesters.
Anaerobic or methane digestion (AD) has been used to produce energy from
livestock waste since the late 1800s. While its efficiency has improved over
the years, it is still based on a biological process that produces biogas
(which generally contains around 60% methane). Bion's patented and proven
nutrient management technology has been developed over the last 20 years to
provide comprehensive environmental treatment of the livestock waste stream.
Bion's Environmental Management System simultaneously (with scale) recovers
substantially more renewable energy than AD.
There has been a great deal of recent publicity surrounding anaerobic
digesters: promoting their ability to recover energy from livestock waste as
well as provide two primary environmental benefits: reduced greenhouse gas
emissions and odors. For instance,
-- A January 2008 press release stated that Oregon's 320 dairy farms could
become power generators through the Dairy Power Initiative from Energy Trust
of Oregon. Dairy farms that install anaerobic digesters can receive cash
incentives to turn manure into biogas, and 'generate climate-safe
electricity.'
-- According to AgStar, a federal program that promotes the conversion of
manure to energy (and the AD process), there are more than 100 anaerobic
digesters operating in the United States today, with another 80 on the drawing
boards.
-- Dean Foods Company, the largest processor and distributor of milk and
other dairy products in the U.S., announced in May that it has begun
development of an anaerobic digester on the Big Sky Dairy farm near Gooding,
Idaho. Dean Foods has partnered with AgPower Partners 'to bring this
important and sustainable dairy industry solution to the market.'
James Morris, PhD, Bion's Chief Technology Officer, stated, "Bion agrees
that AD does produce renewable energy, while reducing greenhouse gas emissions
and odors. However, consumers, the industry and other stakeholders should be
aware of AD's limitations: the technology is not capable of providing a
comprehensive solution to the environmental impacts of concentrated livestock
waste. They should also consider the level of grants and subsidies being
provided for AD installations compared to their relatively limited
environmental benefits."
In the Proposed Rules for CAFO's, published in the Federal Register in
June 2006, the U.S. EPA states, "EPA further notes that [anaerobic] digesters
do not reduce the total nutrients in animal wastes ... Other data show that
changes in pollutant composition, particularly the soluble forms of nitrogen,
could result in increased discharges of pollutants following land application
of digested manure, specifically ammonia releases and other emissions."
Dr. Morris added, "The dairy and livestock industries are under increasing
pressure from their customers and the public in general for 'Green' products
and to adopt environmentally-responsible production practices. Some of our
state and federal agencies are also making positive steps toward responding to
these appeals but are doing so by embracing the limited benefits of AD while
over-looking the many problems associated with livestock waste that AD does
not address.
The commonality between AD (as typically applied) and Bion's Environmental
Management System is that they both reduce odor and greenhouse gas emissions
while producing renewable energy. However it is the differences that are of
the most importance. Only Bion provides a comprehensive multi-media treatment
technology that substantially reduces the more serious environmental impacts
from livestock waste, including nutrient discharges, ammonia and other air
emissions, which AD does not address. In the case of nutrients, the increased
nutrient mobility resulting from AD can potentially increase negative
environmental impacts, unless significant steps are taken to prevent them."
Bion's technology was developed to focus on the reduction of environmental
impacts from livestock waste first, with renewable energy production an
important but secondary benefit of its overall system. Bion's process reduces
nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) in the waste stream effluent between 70
and 95%+, depending on the level of treatment desired. Bion's technology also
reduces ammonia emissions greater than 90% and provides substantially greater
reductions than AD for hydrogen sulfide, greenhouse gases, VOCs, and other
emissions including odors. Bion's renewable energy approach produces
substantially more energy than AD and that energy is in a transportable form
and not required to be used or converted to electricity on-site.
The AD process is focused on energy production. It provides essentially
no reductions in nitrogen and phosphorus in the effluent and actually
increases nutrient solubility, even when compared to land application of
untreated manure. The presence of nutrients in dissolved form increases the
potential for nutrient runoff after the effluent from the AD process is
applied to the land. Along these same lines, AD increases the levels of
dissolved ammonia in the waste stream, which produces an increased potential
for ammonia emissions that have been shown, in sufficient concentrations, to
pose significant potential health risks, as well as contribute to nutrient
loading through downwind redeposition of nitrogen. AD does provide reductions
of greenhouse gases, hydrogen sulfide, VOCs and odors, but these benefits are
a small fraction compared to the control provided by Bion's technology.
From a renewable energy perspective, AD may provide between 25,000 and
30,000 net BTU per dairy cow per day, depending on process design and
operation. In most instances, the gas produced by the AD system is combusted
on-site in a turbine or internal combustion engine to produce electricity. In
most cases, a significant portion of the energy contained in the waste stream
is lost in the conversion to electricity. The economics of AD are such that
substantial public assistance in the form of grants and subsidies is normally
utilized in order to attract investment and implementation.
Bion's comprehensive environmental management system utilizes a
combination of mechanical and patented biological processes to produce a
cellulose-based solid fuel that reclaims approximately 70,000 net BTU per
dairy cow per day -- or about 25.5 MMBTU per year (one MMBTU contains
approximately the same amount of energy as one MCF of natural gas). This fuel
may then be utilized to provide thermal energy to a steam boiler, replacing
the use of natural gas. However, Bion anticipates near-term technology
developments in biomass-to-liquids conversion processes that will enable Bion
to produce even greater value through conversion of the recovered cellulosic
biomass to transportation fuels.
For a detailed comparison of Bion's technology and AD, please visit the
company's website at
www.biontech.com/technology/documents/Bion%20vs%20AD.080613.pdf.
With adequate subsidy, AD provides a biomass to energy solution only in
locations where there is sufficient local acreage to spread nutrients and
where ammonia and other atmospheric emissions are not a concern. Bion may
incorporate AD processes in its own technology platforms to produce energy,
but only as part of an overall solution based on Bion's comprehensive
environmental management system. However, because AD by itself can only
increase the potential for negative nutrient impacts and provides relatively
limited environmental benefits across other media, the technology does not
support permitting new high-density operations, nor does it represent a
solution to existing farms that need to reduce excess nutrients or air
emissions. Only Bion has a proven comprehensive management system that can.
In conclusion, Mark Smith, Bion's president, added, "The cost of the
impact of livestock waste on our environment is just beginning to be
understood. The situation that Pennsylvania (and many of its municipalities)
finds itself in, with regards to the Chesapeake Bay nutrient guidelines, is a
first step in highlighting and quantifying that cost. The Pennsylvania
Department of Environmental Protection recently approved 140 nutrient trading
credits per cow per year (allocating half of the annual 280 pounds of on-farm
nitrogen reductions) at Bion's proposed Lancaster County installation.
Greater than 40% of these credits are generated based on the reduction of
ammonia emissions. Pursuant to Pennsylvania's unique program, these nutrient
reduction credits, which originate from non-point source agricultural
operations, will be available to point source users, including municipal waste
water treatment plants, at $8 to $10 per credit per year from Bion's initial
installation. This cost is significantly less than the alternative of
expensive treatment plant upgrades, many of which are in excess of $30 per
pound per year.
Even considering the substantial savings that the region's municipalities
can achieve by purchasing nutrient credits on a long term basis (as compared
to costly treatment plant capital upgrades), ratepayers will still be
subsidizing the treatment of nutrients from livestock waste in excess of
$1,000 per cow per year. The bottom line is that Pennsylvania's nutrient
credit trading program monetizes the environmental impact of livestock
pollution for the first time. Although the specific financial impact will
vary to some degree in other regions and states, it will nonetheless be very
substantial. While nutrient credits will provide much needed local relief,
the key is that livestock environmental impacts will no longer be discussed
solely in local terms, such as problems with odor and public health issues --
but also as related to the specific financial costs that will be borne by
taxpayers nationwide through federal and state contributions to clean water
and air. This is a national problem that anaerobic digesters cannot address."
About Bion: Bion's patented technology platform largely eliminates the
environmental impacts of livestock facilities, such as dairies and cattle
feedlots. The platform removes up to 95% of the nutrients in the wastewater
effluent and reduces ammonia emissions by greater than 90%. These reductions
are proven, with peer-reviewed data, and they are quickly gaining acceptance
by industry, regulatory and other stakeholders. Bion has been providing
solutions to the livestock industry since 1990.
By substantially reducing the environmental impact of livestock waste,
Bion's technology creates the opportunity to develop sustainable integrated
agriculture operations, comprised of large scale livestock operations balanced
with dedicated food processing and/or highly-efficient biofuel production.
Bion's ability to permit new herds in strategic locations, coupled with
integrating and co-locating the synergistic agribusiness activities,
dramatically reduces transportation costs and maximizes market opportunities.
These state-of-the-art facilities incorporate onsite production and use of
co-products -- including renewable energy produced from the livestock wastes
to replace the natural gas requirements of the project -- and produce
significant advantages in environmental, energy and economic efficiency. For
more information, see Bion's website: www.biontech.com.
This material includes forward-looking statements based on management's
current reasonable business expectations. In this document, the word
'potential,' 'will,' 'proposed' and similar expressions identify certain
forward-looking statements. These statements are made in reliance on the
Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, Section 27A of the Securities act of
1933, as amended. There are numerous risks and uncertainties that could
result in actual results differing materially from expected outcomes.
SOURCE Bion Environmental Technologies, Inc.