Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  SINGAPORE EXCHANGE  >  City Developments Limited    CTDM   SG1R89002252

News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector newsTweets

City Developments : Minority investors in M&C Hotels seek to block takeover by CDL

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
12/14/2017 | 06:37pm CET

A group of minority investors in Millennium & Copthorne Hotels has rejected a takeover offer from the company's majority shareholder and called on other investors to follow suit to defeat the bid, which values the business at 2 billion pounds.

International Value Advisers, MSD Partners, and Classic Fund Management on Thursday said they would not tender their shares into the "highly opportunistic" 620 pence a share offer made by City Developments Limited on Dec. 8 for the 34.8 percent of M&C that it does not own.

The three investment firms said they represented about 37 percent of the shares targeted in CDL's bid.

The offer by CDL, the vehicle of Singaporean billionaire Kwek Leng Beng, is conditional on it securing acceptances from investors with more than 50 percent of the stock not already held by Kwek.

The move by the trio marks an escalation of long-running investor opposition to CDL's bid, which has already forced the Singaporean firm to raise its bid from a 552.5 pence per share proposal that M&C disclosed to the stock market on Oct. 9.

CDL declared its 620 pence a share offer "final" when it made the bid earlier this month, meaning it cannot be increased again.

Given that Kwek is also M&C's chairman, the stance of the investors pits them against the head of the hotelier's board. CDL's bid has also been recommended by M&C's independent directors.

"We will not tender our shares into such an unattractive offer at any time to help CDL reach the acceptance threshold of its offer," the three investors said in a letter to the independent directors.

"It is our desire that other independent shareholders do the same once the offer is formally made, leaving the company to resume its business for the benefit of all its stakeholders."

Shares in the hotelier fell 1.3 percent to 579.5 pence.

M&C owns, runs, invests in, or franchises a total of 137 hotels around the world and at issue is whether CDL's offer reflects the value of the hotelier's property assets.

IVA, MSD and Classic argued in their letter that CDL's bid "fundamentally undervalues" the hotelier, which had a book value of 822 pence per share at the end of 2016.

Furthermore, that book value was based mainly on valuations from 2003 and so also "significantly understates the market value of the company's assets," the trio said.

The committee of independent M&C directors set up to consider the CDL bid said it had "seen and noted the opinions expressed" in the letter and would "respond accordingly in due course". The committee excludes the Singaporean group's appointees to the hotelier's board.

A spokesman for CDL declined to comment.

In October, Fidelity International, another M&C shareholder, also criticised CDL's earlier 552.5 pence a share offer for not reflecting the value of the company's property portfolio.

MSD is the firm that manages the family wealth of IT entrepreneur Michael Dell.

(Story refiled to modify headline)

(Reporting by Ben Martin; Editing by Adrian Croft, Greg Mahlich)

By Ben Martin

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
01/16 MILLENNIUM PTHORNE HOTELS : Singapore's CDL will not extend M&C offer beyond Jan..
01/16 CDL : Announcement on Incorporation of Subsidiaries
01/16 CDL : Scheduled date for release of the Unaudited Financial Results for the Year..
01/12 MILLENNIUM PTHORNE HOTELS : CDL hires Georgeson to woo investors in M&C Hotels b..
01/11 CDLHT : Completion of Divestment of Mercure Brisbane and Ibis Brisbane
01/11 FSGL : Announcement in relation to Update on Acquisition of the Le Meridien Fran..
01/11 CDL : Update on Acquisition of Le Meridien Frankfurt Hotel, Germany
2017 FSGL : Announcement in relation to the acquisition of another office property in..
2017 CDLHT : Press Release on the Proposed Divestment of Mercure Brisbane and Ibis Br..
2017 MILLENNIUM PTHORNE HOTELS : Singaporean billionaire defends bid for M&C Hotels i..
More news
News from SeekingAlpha
2016 City Developments, Ltd. ADR 2016 Q3 - Results - Earnings Call Slides
2016 My Life Is An Experiment - Cheap Stock Digest
2015 Coeur Mining's (CDE) CEO Mitchell Krebs on Q4 2014 Results - Earnings Call Tr..
2015 Coeur Mining beats by $0.06, misses on revenue
Financials ( SGD)
Sales 2017 3 740 M
EBIT 2017 834 M
Net income 2017 582 M
Debt 2017 2 073 M
Yield 2017 1,12%
P/E ratio 2017 22,21
P/E ratio 2018 18,93
EV / Sales 2017 3,83x
EV / Sales 2018 3,52x
Capitalization 12 257 M
Duration : Period :
City Developments Limited Technical Analysis Chart | CTDM | SG1R89002252 | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends CITY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 19
Average target price 14,0  SGD
Spread / Average Target 3,8%
EPS Revisions
Eik Tse Kwek Chief Executive Officer
Leng Beng Kwek Executive Chairman
Yim Ming Yiong Chief Financial Officer
Ivan Ng Chief Technology Officer
Leng Peck Kwek Non-Independent Non-Executive Director
Sector and Competitors