Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Commodities  >  London Sugar       

Mes dernières consult.
Most popular
News SummaryAll newsTweets

United, Pepsi Outcry Unlikely to Hurt Financial Results

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
04/15/2017 | 10:14am CEST
By Tatyana Shumsky 

A social media kerfuffle can bruise a company's reputation, but these incidents rarely leave a red mark on the bottom line.

Video of a passenger being dragged off a United Airlines flight is fanning the latest outrage on social media. Earlier this month, PepsiCo Inc. pulled an advertisement that was panned as culturally insensitive. Starbucks Corp. faced a backlash in January when it said it would hire 10,000 refugees globally.

These incidents often grab consumer attention, but such controversies rarely translate into a material impact on sales or earnings in the absence of serious product issues. When money is paid -- as in the case of United Continental Holdings Inc. refunding the ticket costs to all customers on the 70-seat flight -- the effect is barely a rounding error on the quarterly results.

"There's no way that [refunding] one flight would be material to United's total financial condition," said Trent Gazzaway, national managing partner of professional standards at accounting firm Grant Thornton.

There is also scarce executive disclosure of these events in financial filings because they are not considered material, or likely to change a reasonable shareholder's investment decision.

A review of filings by companies including United Continental, Pepsi and Starbucks showed they so far haven't disclosed the social media incidents to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

"Social media interest by itself may not be material enough to warrant a disclosure in the financial statements," said Olga Usvyatsky, vice president of research and CPA at Audit Analytics, an audit, regulatory and disclosure research firm.

Companies typically make such disclosures, like flagging the effect of a severe storm or a cyberbreach of corporate computer systems, in quarterly reports or a so-called Form 8-K, used to notify investors of a current event that could be material to the company or affect the stock price.

A social media uproar should prompt executives to assess the potential for a material impact from a corporate-disclosure perspective. "This is a massive area of judgment for CFOs," Mr. Gazzaway said.

When determining materiality, executives weigh quantitative factors, like whether income or sales are likely to fall below a company-determined threshold, as well as qualitative factors, which are less clearly defined.

A United Airlines spokeswoman declined to comment on questions about the materiality of the incident. The company is due to report its first-quarter earnings on Monday after markets close. In January, it posted fourth-quarter earnings of $397 million on revenue of $9.05 billion.

United Continental stock fell last Monday, the day the video came out, though analysts attributed the move to mixed operational data released that morning. The stock ended the week down 2.6%, and the Dow Jones U.S. airlines index fell 0.9%.

"Historically, incidents like this are one-off in nature and rarely pose lasting or significant financial headwinds for major transportation companies," analysts at Citigroup said in a note to clients.

Still, consumer-facing companies, which are particularly vulnerable to social controversies, should outline such risks and response strategies in financial filings, said Nell Minow, vice chair of corporate governance consulting firm ValueEdge Advisors.

"They need to let their investors know that they're prepared to deal with it promptly and effectively to prevent a material deterioration of the stock price," Ms. Minow said. "It's very much like cyberattacks -- it's a relatively recent phenomenon that every company has to be prepared to deal with."

PepsiCo likely paid as much as $30 million in talent and production costs of the ad it scrapped in response to the social media outcry, said Gene Grabowski, a crisis management specialist at communications firm kglobal.

"For Pepsi, in this situation, there might be some short-term impact, but long-term, it's doubtful," Mr. Grabowski said, adding that the company has built up strong consumer loyalty over its history. "Pepsi is an old brand, and a lot of consumers may not care about this."

Starbucks in January sparked social media calls for a boycott after Chairman and Chief Executive Howard Schultz said the coffee-store chain would hire 10,000 refugees globally. Some customers criticized the announcement on Twitter, with the hashtag #BoycottStarbucks trending on the social-media network for several days.

Mr. Schultz addressed the issue at the company's annual shareholder meeting in March.

"I can unequivocally tell you, and we all know this from the research we've done, that there is zero, absolutely no evidence whatsoever that there is any dilution in the integrity of the Starbucks brand, reputation or our core business as a result of being compassionate," Mr. Schultz said.

Write to Tatyana Shumsky at [email protected]

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
LONDON COFFEE -0.23% 1729 End-of-day quote.0.17%
PEPSICO, INC. -0.64% 118.26 End-of-day quote.13.36%
STARBUCKS CORPORATION -0.42% 57.1 Delayed Quote.-0.16%
UNITED CONTINENTAL HOLDINGS INC 0.88% 70.33 Delayed Quote.3.96%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on LONDON SUGAR
05/21Sugar Prices Climb to Month High
05/17SUEDZUCKER : to step up exports to boost revenues after sugar price slump
05/15KELLOGG : Pulls Out of Venezuela, Citing Its 'Deterioration'
05/15KELLOGG : Pulls Out of Venezuela, Citing Its 'Deterioration' -- Update
05/09Starbucks Wants More P.M. Buzz -- WSJ
05/08Starbucks Trying to Woo Afternoon Customers
05/07Nestlé to Sell Starbucks Coffee, Tea in Retail Stores -- 2nd Update
05/07Flavors Giant Adds Israeli Spice in $6.4 Billion Deal
05/07Nestlé Inks Deal to Sell Starbucks Products World-Wide -- Update
05/07Nestlé Inks Deal to Sell Starbucks Products World-Wide -- Update
More news
Duration : Period :
London Sugar Technical Analysis Chart | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends LONDON SUGAR
Short TermMid-TermLong Term