Log in
E-mail
Password
Remember
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Settings
Settings
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nyse  >  Morgan Stanley    MS

Delayed Quote. Delayed  - 08/25 10:02:32 pm
30.97 USD   +0.19%
08:48aDJFinance Watch -- WSJ
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates WOW as Underweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates SXL as Underweight
SummaryQuotesChartsNewsAnalysisCalendarCompanyFinancialsConsensusRevisions 
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector news 

Goldman agonized over pay cuts as profits suffered

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
0
01/17/2013 | 06:10am CEST

Top executives at Goldman Sachs (>> Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.) have been considering deep cuts to staffing levels and pay for at least two years, but feared too many layoffs would leave the firm unprepared for an eventual pickup in business, people familiar with the bank said.

Top executives at Goldman Sachs (>> Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.) have been considering deep cuts to staffing levels and pay for at least two years, but feared too many layoffs would leave the firm unprepared for an eventual pickup in business, people familiar with the bank said.

They instead chipped away at staff levels and focused on non-personnel expenses that are less painful to cut.

But investors pressured the bank to cut costs further, the sources said, and on Wednesday, Goldman gave in.

The largest standalone investment bank said in the fourth quarter it cut the percentage of revenues it pays to employees in half to 21 percent. That brings the ratio for the entire year to its second-lowest level since the bank went public in 1999.

With less money going to employees, more was available for shareholders. The bank's annualized return on equity - which measures how well the bank uses shareholder money to generate profit - jumped to 16.5 percent in the fourth quarter from 5.8 percent a year earlier.

"Arguably for the first time, Wall Street's shareholders are getting the lion's share of the profitability," said Brad Hintz, a former Morgan Stanley treasurer who is now an analyst at Bernstein Research.

The bank's quarterly profit tripled, helped by gains from investments and bond trading as well, and investors sent its shares up 4 percent to $141.09, their highest level since 2006.

Analysts said other banks are likely to feel pressure to keep their compensation expenses in check after Goldman's results. But for Morgan Stanley (>> Morgan Stanley), the second-biggest stand-alone U.S. investment bank, paying out a lower percentage of its revenue to employees could be tough because analysts believe its revenue fell last year.

Goldman missed the worst pitfalls of the financial crisis but has suffered public relations embarrassments from trades it executed during the crisis and from executives' comments afterward. The bank, along with the rest of the industry, is struggling to figure out how to navigate the post-crisis world, in which clients trade less and regulations and capital rules crimp profits in many businesses.

Whether Goldman maintains its discipline on pay will be a test for Harvey Schwartz, who succeeds David Viniar as CFO at the end of this month.

On a conference call with investors, Schwartz declined to provide a target for compensation levels, but emphasized that shareholder returns would be one crucial factor in deciding how much revenue goes to employee pay.

"We don't look to overpay anybody," Schwartz said.

YEARS OF COST-CUTTING

Goldman first publicly signaled its intent to get serious about cost-cutting in July 2011, when Viniar outlined a plan to reduce costs by $1.2 billion a year, partly by laying off employees. Since then, Goldman expanded that cost-cutting plan by $500 million and has winnowed staff almost every quarter.

Staff reductions have targeted big earners, including dozens of partners, who have left since the start of 2011. Sources inside the bank expect that exodus to continue this year as Goldman makes way for younger employees to move up the ladder.

Analysts say that strategy is common.

"The polite way to characterize it is a ?generational change' - where you promote the young guys and you don't pay them," said Hintz.

In 2008, as the bank's revenue dropped, average pay per employee fell as well. While the average Goldman worker brought home nearly $622,000 in pay in 2006, that figure dropped to $367,057 per person in 2011, with the biggest decline happening between 2007 and 2008. But the percentage of revenue that the bank paid to employees did not stop falling until now.

The fourth-quarter drop meant that for all of 2012, Goldman paid employees 37.9 percent of the bank's revenue, down from 42 percent in the previous year.

"Management appears to be doing a superb job at keeping all expenses down and, in particular, retaining quality people without giving all the revenue away in the form of compensation," said Joe Terril, president of St. Louis-based investment firm Terril & Co, who invests in bank stocks.

WALL STREET WOES

Many banks are facing the same long-term revenue pressure as Goldman, and analysts expect layoffs across Wall Street. Morgan Stanley plans 1,600 job cuts in 2013, while Goldman cut 900 jobs in 2012, equal to about 3 percent of its workforce.

But laying off staff may not be enough, and employee pay may have to fall too. Hintz, the Bernstein Research analyst, estimates that across Wall Street average pay in trading businesses could fall 20 percent.

"There's only one way to get returns up on Wall Street, and that's to cut the compensation of the employees," Hintz said.

Investors have been pressuring banks to pay less of their revenue to employees. In 2011, investors pressed Morgan Stanley executives to pay somewhere closer to 30 percent of the bank's revenue to employees, instead of around 50 percent, according to one person at those meetings.

(Reporting by Lauren Tara LaCapra; Editing by Dan Wilchins, Paritosh Bansal and Ryan Woo)

By Lauren Tara LaCapra

Stocks treated in this article : Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., Morgan Stanley
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
0
Latest news on MORGAN STANLEY
08:48aDJFinance Watch -- WSJ
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates WOW as Underweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates TRS as Equal-weight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates SXL as Underweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates SMX as Equal-weight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates S32 as Overweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates ILU as Overweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates IDX as Overweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates CMW as Underweight
02:31a MORGAN STANLEY : rates AWE as Overweight
More news
Sector news : Investment Banking & Brokerage Services - NEC
08/25DJCIBC Revenue and Profit Rise
08/24DJBlockchain Firm R3 Files for a Patent as Fintech Race Heats Up--Update
08/24DJGOLDMAN SACHS : Funds Loan Firm -- WSJ
08/24DJHONG KONG EXCHANGES AND CLEARING : China's Postal Savings Bank to Get $2 Billion..
08/23DJSpotify in Talks Over Music Rights
More sector news : Investment Banking & Brokerage Services - NEC
News from SeekingAlpha
08/24 Big Bank Shareholder Activism Is Here
08/22 75% Gain From Bidder War As Pfizer Beats All Challengers
08/22 Tracking Jeffrey Ubben's ValueAct Portfolio - Q2 2016 Update
08/22 Who Is To Blame For Merchant Refiners' High Regulatory Costs?
08/22 IT'S TOO LATE FOR THE FED TO RAISE R : Here's Why
Advertisement
Financials ($)
Sales 2016 32 841 M
EBIT 2016 7 523 M
Net income 2016 4 618 M
Debt 2016 -
Yield 2016 2,31%
P/E ratio 2016 12,81
P/E ratio 2017 10,62
Capi. / Sales 2016 1,80x
Capi. / Sales 2017 1,72x
Capitalization 59 209 M
More Financials
Chart MORGAN STANLEY
Duration : Period :
Morgan Stanley Technical Analysis Chart | MS | US6174464486 | 4-Traders
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends MORGAN STANLEY
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
TrendsBullishBullishNeutral
Technical analysis
Income Statement Evolution
More Financials
Consensus
Sell
Buy
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 26
Average target price 32,5 $
Spread / Average Target 4,9%
Consensus details
EPS Revisions
More Estimates Revisions
Managers
NameTitle
James Patrick Gorman Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Thomas Colm Kelleher President
James A. Rosenthal Chief Operating Officer & Executive Vice President
Paul C. Wirth Director-Finance & Controller
Jonathan Pruzan Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
More about the company
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
MORGAN STANLEY-2.64%59 094
GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP IN..-7.95%67 023
CHARLES SCHWAB CORP-7.41%39 994
CITIC SECURITIES COMPA..-13.64%29 773
GUOSEN SECURITIES CO L..--.--%21 808
HUATAI SECURITIES CO.,..2.03%20 173
More Results