Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nyse  >  Yum Brands    YUM

Mes dernières consult.
Most popular
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector newsTweets

U.S. multinationals fear fallout from U.S.- China audit row

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
12/07/2012 | 06:18am CET

SINGAPORE/NEW YORK (Reuters) - A dispute between U.S. and Chinese regulators over access to corporate audit documents is casting a lengthening shadow over U.S. stock markets, with some major U.S. firms now concerned that they could be drawn into a potential accounting crisis.

The dispute centers on Beijing's refusal to give U.S. regulators access to audit records for nine U.S.-listed Chinese companies, a standoff that has so far focused minds only on the implications for the future of U.S.-traded Chinese stocks.

However, accounting experts say the issue has the potential to not only force Chinese firms to de-list from U.S. markets, it could also put U.S.-based firms with big Chinese businesses in a position where they have difficulty producing audited accounts.

"The potential consequences of failure to find common ground are almost too frightening to contemplate," said Thomas Shoesmith, a partner at Pillsbury law firm in a note to clients.

This week, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged the Chinese affiliates of five of the world's biggest audit firms with violating U.S. securities law, raising fears that it could go on to apply its ultimate penalty - banning the affiliates from working on audits of U.S.-listed companies.

"If these five accounting firms are barred from practicing before the SEC, it seems certain that companies with major Chinese operations will find it difficult or impossible to find accountants," Shoesmith said.

U.S. firms with major Chinese businesses include fast food group Yum Brands Inc, tech firm Qualcomm and construction equipment maker Caterpillar. Some have begun to show concern about the possible impact of the dispute.

"It would impact us and any other U.S. company with significant operations in China," said Yum spokesman Jonathan Blum.

"Essentially, there would be no auditors in China that the U.S. government would recognize. It will require a diplomatic resolution, I believe, and we are monitoring the situation."

Caterpillar also appeared anxious for a settlement.

"As this issue revolves around differences between U.S. and Chinese regulators, Caterpillar hopes each side can work to resolve this issue while demonstrating mutual respect and understanding for the laws and regulations of each country," the company said in an emailed response to questions.

Multinationals operating in China commonly use Chinese affiliates of the so-called Big Four audit firms - Deloitte, KPMG, PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) and Ernst & Young - to audit their Chinese business divisions.

These four dominate world auditing to an extent that U.S. firms would have trouble finding alternative auditors for their Chinese businesses if the affiliates of all four were barred.


In China, the affiliates say they are prevented by state secrecy laws from releasing audit papers to U.S. regulators.

Washington's reach is also hampered by the structure of the auditing groups themselves, which are set up as global networks of legally separate, national affiliates aimed at insulating the groups from difficulties felt in specific jurisdictions.

The standoff is seen as a test of China's ability and willingness to comply with international capital-market norms as it takes on the role of global economic superpower. At the same time, U.S. regulators are in largely uncharted waters, with little experience in dealing with foreign defiance.

The SEC began proceedings on Monday against the Chinese affiliates of the Big Four as well as second-tier audit firm BDO. The charges centre on the affiliates' refusal to turn over to U.S. authorities the paperwork from audits of nine U.S.-listed Chinese companies suspected of possible wrong-doing.

Months of talks between the Chinese Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) and U.S. regulators have failed to reach a solution, and lawyers struggle to see a way forward.

"The CSRC won't back down on the State Secrecy Law," said James Zimmerman, a lawyer in Beijing at Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton.

"If the SEC and CSRC are unable to find common ground and reach a consensus, China can expect that the U.S. will stall or refuse to cooperate in other ways in the future. Then it becomes tit for tat," he added.

The SEC and CSRC both signed a 2002 memorandum of understanding to exchange information to help each other enforce their laws, but the agreement is not legally binding.

Under rules set by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), the U.S. audit industry watchdog, an audit firm needs to be registered with the watchdog if it looks over more than 20 percent of a company's consolidated assets or revenue.

Yum, Qualcomm and chip-maker Advanced Micro Devices are among U.S. firms that draw more than a fifth of their revenues from China.

If diplomacy fails, accounting experts say the SEC may have no choice but to stop the Chinese affiliates from auditing U.S.-listed firms. Then, the PCAOB could move to de-register them.

If that happens, multinational companies (MNC) might struggle to file their financial accounts.

"That could lead to the inability of the U.S. (auditing) firm to sign off on the audit of the MNC, since it has no way to audit the China operations," wrote Paul Gillis, a professor at Peking University on his China Accounting Blog.

One way around the problem would be to split the audit among several firms, so that no one auditor is playing "a substantial role", Gillis added, noting that only auditors playing a substantial role would need to be registered with the PCAOB.

But he said that solution would be expensive and likely to reduce audit quality.


Most analysts remain optimistic a solution will be reached before the SEC deploys these sanctions, but papers filed this week by the SEC in a court case against Deloitte Touche Tohmatstu CPA Ltd suggest a solution is still some way off.

The SEC wants documents related to Deloitte's audit of Chinese software firm Longtop Technologies, which delisted in the United States after an accounting scandal.

"In short, the CSRC remains unwilling or unable to provide the SEC with meaningful assistance in its enforcement investigations," the papers said.

The CSRC has not commented on the issue since the SEC charged the Chinese auditing affiliates, but it indicated recently that both sides were trying to reach a solution.

"Audit papers are very important to maintain market integrity and the CSRC is ready to cooperate with other jurisdictions on this issue," CSRC director general of international affairs Tong Daochi said at a Thomson Reuters regulation conference last week.

"We have engaged with the SEC, SFC (Hong Kong's regulator) and PCAOB on audit working papers and we are making progress and I think we should be able to work out a way to get them out."

(Reporting by Rachel Armstrong and Dena Aubin; Additional reporting by Ernest Scheyder in NEW YORK, Vikram Subheadar in HONG KONG, Kevin Drawbaugh and Andy Quinn in WASHINGTON, and the Beijing newsroom; Editing by Mark Bendeich)

By Rachel Armstrong and Dena Aubin

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES, INC. 1.52% 2.67 End-of-day quote.-31.01%
CATERPILLAR 1.22% 156.46 Delayed Quote.-1.91%
QUALCOMM 1.22% 60.62 Delayed Quote.-6.45%
YUM BRANDS 0.75% 83.5 Delayed Quote.1.56%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on YUM BRANDS
03/14CHIPOTLE MEXICAN GRILL : marketing chief resigns days after new CEO takes charge
03/08YUM BRANDS : KFC returning to former supplier in UK after chicken shortage
03/06YUM BRANDS : Expands Commitment to Diversity and Inclusion; Yum! Brands' commitm..
03/05DON'T MISS A SECOND OF MARCH MADNESS : Pizza Hut® Unveils The Pie Tops II Sneake..
03/02El Pollo Loco Hires New CEO
03/02YUM BRANDS : Mary Nixon appointed to board of trustees
03/01YUM BRANDS : At KFC's UK restaurants, it's not all gravy
03/01YUM BRANDS : At KFC's UK restaurants, it's not all gravy
03/01PAPA JOHN 'L : NFL, Papa John's split; another Louisville-based company takes le..
03/01YUM BRANDS : Gravy shortage now plagues KFC UK, Ireland
More news
News from SeekingAlpha
03/10STOCKS TO WATCH : Back To Basics Time 
03/09Restaurant same-store sales dip in February 
03/03Tariffs, Wages And Target In The Bull's-eye 
03/01The Next Ones Beat The Index By Almost 3% In 2017 
02/28Is Domino's Pizza Still A Buy After It Missed Revenues? 
Financials ($)
Sales 2018 4 467 M
EBIT 2018 1 781 M
Net income 2018 1 100 M
Debt 2018 8 762 M
Yield 2018 1,69%
P/E ratio 2018 25,31
P/E ratio 2019 21,73
EV / Sales 2018 8,18x
EV / Sales 2019 8,52x
Capitalization 27 765 M
Duration : Period :
Yum Brands Technical Analysis Chart | YUM | US9884981013 | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends YUM BRANDS
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 23
Average target price 85,4 $
Spread / Average Target 2,3%
EPS Revisions
Greg Creed Chief Executive Officer & Director
David W. Gibbs President & Chief Financial Officer
Robert D. Walter Non-Executive Chairman
Tom C. Nelson Independent Director
Mirian M. Graddick-Weir Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
YUM BRANDS1.56%27 765
DOMINO'S PIZZA, INC.21.61%9 920
WENDYS CO4.14%4 059