Editor's Note: FMSO's Operational Environment
Watch provides translated selections and analysis from a
diverse range of foreign articles and other media that
analysts and expert contributors believe will give military
and security experts an added dimension to their critical
thinking about the Operational Environment.
Sources: "Dar pai efsha saazi 8 Sobh, modakhela rasaana-yi
Iran barasee meshawad" [
After disclosure by Hasht-e Sobh, Iran's media interference
is being investigated], 14 August 2012
On 3 August Iran's embassy in Kabul hosted an iftaar dinner
for a group of Afghan media officials to discuss
establishing a "union of journalists" to coordinate the
work of pro-Iran media in Afghanistan. According to a
report in the daily Hasht-e Sobh, representatives from
major Afghan broadcast and print outlets attended the
meeting, including Tamaddon (Civilization) TV, Noor (Light)
TV, Ayna (Mirror) TV, Insaaf [Justice] (a daily newspaper),
and Roshd [Progress] (a daily newspaper). Iranian cultural
attaché Naser Jahan-Shahi chaired the meeting and pledged
that the embassy would cover the expenses for the project.
The meeting selected Hussein Rezvani Bamyani, Director of
the Cultural Committee of Afghanistan's Shia Ulema
[Scholar] Council, as the head of the union. Jawad Mohseni,
director of Tamaddon TV, and Zakaria Rahel, a prominent
journalist, were appointed the first and second deputies
respectively. Bamyani has close ties with the Iranian
clerical establishment in Qom and promotes the teachings of
Iranian revolutionary leader Grand Ayatollah Ruhollah
Khomeini in Afghanistan. He has organized several anti-West
and anti-Israel protest rallies in Kabul over the past
years.
The leaked information alarmed many Afghans. Lawmakers and
civil society activists condemned the initiative as
overt interference in Afghan affairs. Afghanistan's upper
house of parliament has tasked the country's intelligence
agency to investigate the issue. As the U.S. and NATO are
winding down the war in Afghanistan, Iran has launched an
aggressive campaign of hard power and soft power to speed
up the withdrawal of foreign troops and maximize its
influence in Afghanistan.
While Iran's weapons and financial aid to the Taliban often
make headlines, Tehran's soft power efforts in Afghanistan
at the expense of U.S. interests are largely overlooked.
According to Davood Moradian, former senior policy advisor
at Afghanistan's Foreign Ministry, Iran spends $100 million
a year in Afghanistan on funding media, religious and
cultural organizations. Quoting Afghan officials, a report
in Reuters in May said Iran funded about one-third of
Afghanistan's media, either financially or by providing
content and direction.
As the article in Hasht-e Sobh points out, Iran through
funding media aims to incite anti- American sentiments and
strain ties between Afghanistan and the United States. As
Kabul and Washington worked on drafting a Strategic
Partnership Agreement (SPA) earlier this year, Iran waged a
multilayered campaign to derail the pact. It tried to bribe
Afghan lawmakers to reject the deal, and pro-Iran media
outlets depicted the agreement as a U.S. tool to occupy
Afghanistan. Despite all Iranian efforts, the Afghan
parliament approved the pact.
Over the past decade Iran has played a two-faced game in
Afghanistan. Tehran has fostered close ties to Kabul, aided
Afghanistan's rebuilding, and invested in the country's
industry and mining. Trade between Iran and Afghanistan
increased from $800 million in 2008 to $2 billion last
year. Conversely, Iran's Revolutionary Guards have provided
weapons and money to the Taliban, fueled sectarian tension
between the Sunnis and Shias, bribed Afghan politicians to
influence policy in Kabul, and funded religious and media
organizations to advance its own agenda.
Iran's short-term and long-term objectives in Afghanistan
appear to contradict one another. In the long term, Iran
favors a stable, multiethnic, and friendly Afghanistan.
Iran is politically and ideologically opposed to the
Taliban and sees the extremist Sunni group as an instrument
of its regional rivals Pakistan and Saudi Arabia. At
present, however, due to perceived threats of a military
action against its nuclear facilities, Iran sees the
presence of U.S. troops in Afghanistan as a bigger threat.
It, therefore, has accelerated its hard power and soft
power efforts to drive the United States out of
Afghanistan.