Member access

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersVideosCalendar 

China's Stock Regulator Expected to Leave

03/13/2013 | 06:56pm US/Eastern

BEIJING -- China's new leaders plan to reassign the country's top securities regulator, who has sought to clean up the country's stock markets and attract foreign capital, after only 18 months on the job, say Communist Party officials with knowledge of the decision, raising questions about how quickly and deeply the leaders want to reform the financial sector and take on powerful interests.

Since Guo Shuqing took the reins of the China Securities Regulatory Commission in October 2011, he has moved to shore up investor confidence by tackling insider trading and made stock-listing standards tougher.

His efforts to bring China's equities market closer to the Western model, expand bond markets and weed out bad candidates for initial public offerings have been applauded by investors both inside and outside China.

But they have put him on a direct collision course with state-owned enterprises looking to go public, state-owned banks worried about competition from domestic bond issuers, and other regulatory agencies whose roles have diminished.

Now China's leaders are planning to remove Mr. Guo from the CSRC and make him governor of China's eastern Shandong province, the party officials said. The shift would mean that Mr. Guo, a fluent English speaker who is more comfortable with the media than many other senior Chinese officials, would be absent from the debate on how fast China should open its capital markets as part of a broader plan to transform China's economy so it relies more on domestic demand.

Mr. Guo's role in lifting the role of stocks and bonds in the financing of growth in China hasn't endeared him to entrenched interest groups such as state-owned banks. Traditionally, corporations in China generally turn to banks for credit, which has underpinned profit of state-controlled lenders that bankroll China's large state-owned companies. The listing process favors state-owned companies promoted by their provincial-government backers.

The arrangement has led to complaints by smaller companies in the private sector that they can't get needed financing. "The most pressing problem facing the Chinese economy at present is the difficulty in obtaining financing for small and micro enterprises," Mr. Guo wrote in the Chinese magazine Caixin last year.

With a more vigorous bond market, Chinese banking executives say some of their customers might turn to bonds to raise capital, instead of taking loans, which could hurt banks' profits.

"Guo may have threatened the comfortable nexus between large state-owned banks, provincial governments and state-owned enterprises," said Eswar Prasad, a former senior International Monetary Fund China scholar who now teaches at Cornell University. "That could have proved to be his undoing."

Mr. Guo isn't expected to take his new post for several weeks, the party officials say, which could leave time for additional lobbying. "It's all but a done deal," said one of the party officials, who added that Mr. Guo isn't contesting the decision. The official said that the fact that Mr. Guo needed to deal with different interest groups was a contributing factor in his planned departure.

The South China Morning Post reported on Wednesday that Mr. Guo was headed to Shandong province, one of the biggest agricultural and industrial producers in the country. In a statement to The Wall Street Journal, a CSRC spokesman said "we haven't received any such information" about Mr. Guo's reassignment.

Bank of China Chairman Xiao Gang is now expected to succeed Mr. Guo at the CSRC, said the party officials.

Initially, the leaders decided to appoint Mr. Xiao to a deputy position at the People's Bank of China, expecting that central-bank Gov. Zhou Xiaochuan would groom him to take over in several years, according to several party officials with knowledge of the matter. But that arrangement was later viewed as unworkable.

While Mr. Xiao, 54 years old, is also considered a proponent of financial liberalization, who led Bank of China's expansion domestically, it is far from clear whether he will continue Mr. Guo's policies, or take a more cautious approach, said several Chinese banking executives.

"This [personnel] move is telling you, "Don't be a reformer,'" said Fraser Howie, co-author of "Red Capitalism," a study of China's financial system. "If you're a reformer on the securities beat, you're out of a job in 18 months."

China's stock market has been one of the weakest parts of its remarkable economic rise. The Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges, opened in the early 1990s, have been riddled with allegations of fraudulent accounting practices, poor corporate governance and inadequate information disclosure. Still, stock prices rose steadily in the 1990s and soared nearly fourfold from 2006 to 2007 before giving back the gains during the global financial crisis that began in 2008. The rise and fall of the market convinced many Chinese that investing in stocks was little different from betting in a casino.

In the Chinese system, a provincial governor is equal in rank to a regulatory chief, so Mr. Guo's transfer isn't considered a demotion, and he may be able to make a comeback on the national stage. The party often dispatches candidates for top jobs to provincial leadership roles to give them a broader experience. Indeed, Mr. Guo was a deputy governor of impoverished Guizhou province from 1998 to 2001 when he was in his early 40s.

Now, though, at age 56, he has a limited number of years to get another senior central-government job. Ministers and top regulators in China are generally required to retire at age 65, though exceptions are made.

Top party leaders have been engaged in behind-the-scenes discussions for months about filling top jobs. The PBOC's Mr. Zhou appeared headed for retirement when he was passed over last fall for a slot on the 205-member Central Committee, which makes senior personnel and policy decisions. He reached the retirement age of 65 in January.

But Mr. Zhou was able to call on the formidable backing of former Chinese Party leader Jiang Zemin and former Premier Zhu Rongji to keep his job, said party officials. At a Wednesday news conference, Mr. Zhou said it wasn't clear whether he would remain. "There are procedures for deciding" who becomes PBOC chief, he said.

The decision to retain Mr. Zhou created a bottleneck. Mr. Xiao, the Bank of China chairman, had already been promoted to the central committee -- meaning he was expected to take a ministerial job, possibly replacing Mr. Zhou as PBOC chief.

In recent days, China's leaders decided to move Mr. Guo to the Shandong governorship, party officials said, a move that opened the CSRC chairmanship for Mr. Xiao. Officials in Bank of China's press department declined to comment.

The two moves send mixed signals. Mr. Zhou's expected reappointment was seen as a move to keep reform at a steady pace. Mr. Guo's planned departure is viewed as sending the opposite signal by Chinese financial officials. The conflicting signals may reflect that in Mr. Guo's case, personnel battles inside the party have taken precedence over the desire for continuity.

"Every time there's a new political leadership, we put on them our dreams and aspirations for China," said Mr. Howie, "instead of realizing that the officials come up through the party and are subject to the constraints of that system."

Mr. Guo has long been identified with the forces pushing for market-oriented change. In 1986, he studied at Oxford University's St. Anthony's college and became "one of the first thinkers in China to discuss the need for an overall plan for economic reform," rather than approach changes in a piecemeal fashion, said Pieter Bottelier, a former World Bank chief in China.

In the 1990s, Mr. Guo was a top adviser to Mr. Zhu, who became China's premier and negotiated its entry into the World Trade Organization.

At the CSRC, Mr. Guo has pressed for changes that would shift more power from government officials to auditors and investment banks. Currently, companies are cleared to launch IPOs when they can win political approval from the central government rather than when they need capital.

The market has largely shrugged off his efforts. The benchmark Shanghai Composite Index has dropped 4% since October 2011 when Mr. Guo took office, compared with a 19% gain in the NYSE composite index and a 20% gain in FTSE 100. Market capitalization of the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges is about 23 trillion yuan ($3.7 trillion), less than one-fourth the size of the New York Stock Exchange alone.

The CSRC has stepped up its scrutiny of IPO applicants. Partly as a result, there has been only a trickle of new IPOs on Mr. Guo's watch and an outright moratorium since October. The pipeline of companies queuing to list in either Shanghai or Shenzhen has increased to nearly 880 companies at the end of January, up from about 500 when the CSRC first started disclosing such figures in early 2012.

In 2012, the CSRC suspended its review of about 70 companies that had applied to launch IPOs. Some of those have since withdrawn their application. Analysts say the backlog of IPOs will take years to clear.

Some of China's leaders may have been growing impatient with Mr. Guo. At last year's National People's Congress, Premier Wen Jiabao promised that the government would better protect investors and improve IPOs -- essentially endorsing Mr. Guo's agenda. This year, Mr. Wen, who is retiring as premier, didn't mention the stock market as a priority.

"Guo has done a lot of sensible things and really tried to solve some of the persistent problems in China's market, such as insider trading," said Frank Yao, senior portfolio manager for Neuberger Berman's Greater China team. "But it will take a few years to see what kind of the impact those measures will have on the market."

---

Dinny McMahon and Amy Li contributed to this article.

React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
1m ago SEMPRA ENERGY : SoCalGas offers holiday tips that can keep customers safe
2m ago Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Laminating Apparatus of Manufacturing Organic Light Emitting Display", for Approval
2m ago CHENG UEI PRECISION INDUSTRY : Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Failure Alarm System and Method of Failure Alarming Thereof", for Approval
2m ago Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Electric Charging Apparatus and Failure Determination Method Therefor", for Approval
2m ago NVIDIA : Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Hierarchical Hash Tables for Simt Processing and a Method of Establishing Hierarchical Hash Tables", for...
2m ago Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Load Sensing System with Flexure Plate", for Approval
2m ago Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Linear Motor Device and Method for Controlling Linear Motor Device", for Approval
2m ago KONICA MINOLTA : Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Image Forming Apparatus, Method for Guidance on Operation Method by Image Forming Apparatus, and System", for...
2m ago Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Generating Retail Promotion Baselines", for Approval
2m ago HTC : Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Image Adjusting Method, Light Source Module and Electronic Device", for Approval
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
FINSBURY FOOD : Strong start for Finsbury after bumper deal
BRITVIC : *ubs cuts britvic price target to 700 (740) pence - 'neutral'
PARTNERSHIP ASSURANCE : Q4 Trading To Date In Line With Forecast
MOBILE NETWORK : Researchers Submit Patent Application, "Lifecycle Configuration of Mobile Subscriber", for Approval
MOL GLOBAL : Gainey McKenna & Egleston Announces a Class Action Lawsuit Has Been Filed Against MOL Global, Inc.
Most Read News
1d ago GOPRO : Hero 3 Christmas Discount Covered in New Price Guide at ReelGifts.com
1d ago APPLE : Global tablets expected to slow in 2015, led by iPad shipment downturn
1d agoDJWAL MART STORES : Cuts Nearly 30 Directors and Midlevel Managers in China--Spokesman
1d ago U.S. regulator orders national Takata driver-side air bag recall
1d ago SYNERGY PHARMACEUTICALS : Announces Positive Results of SP-333 Phase 2 Trial in Patients with Opioid-Induced Constipation
Most recommended articles
13m ago AIRBUS : Lion Group set to buy ATR planes in nearly $1 billion deal
14m agoDJIndia Unlikely to Appeal Vodafone and Shell Tax Cases
14m agoDJToyota Says Takata Rupture in Japan Happened in a Toyota
20m ago Euro Vulnerable as German CPI, Draghi Commentary Looms Ahead
21m ago Timeline - Takata air bag recalls
Dynamic quotes  
ON
| OFF