Member access

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersVideosCalendar 

Comment is free: In brief: The Johansson fiasco shows the importance of an honest debate on Israel's illegal actions

01/31/2014 | 12:47pm US/Eastern

Global charities seek global ambassadors to help them raise the profile of their work. Simply doing their best to stem the tide of suffering is not enough to gain them attention. But if a celebrity goes among the poor on behalf of the charity, the media flocks to cover the story - or at least the fact that the celebrity is there. The nuts and bolts of inequality are often overlooked, but the charity gets its name in print or on the television. This is the sorry state our humanism has reached.

It is precisely because of this that Oxfam turned to Scarlett Johansson in 2007 to become its global ambassador. She travelled to Oxfam projects, something that provided photo opportunities for herself and for Oxfam.

In January, Johansson was appointed the brand ambassador for SodaStream, an Israeli company with a factory in the Israeli settlement of Maale Adumim, near Jerusalem.

Israeli settlements are built on land seized from the Palestinians during the 1967 war. By the standards of the Geneva convention, the Rome statute and the international court of justice, they have been developed illegally by Israel. Israel has thumbed its nose at international law and continued to build its settlements, including industrial parks such as the one that houses SodaStream.

The EU has called the E1 parcel of land that Israel plans to build on, extending from Maale Adumim, "a violation of international humanitarian law". Johansson, in other words, had become the face of illegal Israeli settlement activity.

Johansson's new job posed a problem for Oxfam. The charity has over the years taken a strong position against Israel's illegal settlement construction at the same time as it has worked to deliver much-needed goods and services to the encaged population in the occupied Palestinian territories.

In a powerful briefing paper from 2012, Oxfam called on Israel to "immediately halt the construction of all illegal settlements" and end "policies and practices that are illegal under international law and harm the livelihood of Palestinian civilians".

Maale Adumim is built on the rubble of the Palestinian villages of Abu Dis, Al Izriyyeh, Al Issawiyyeh, Al Tur, Khan al Ahmar and Anata - names that exist now only in the memory of their displaced residents. How could Oxfam retain its global ambassador when her new job would undermine its principles? Pro-Palestinian activists began to put pressure on Oxfam and Johansson to make a choice - either she breaks her contract with SodaStream and remains Oxfam's global ambassador, or Oxfam cuts itself off from her complicity with settlement activity.

Within the US, the question of boycotting Israel has become an important political issue, with the vote by the American Studies Association - and other scholarly bodies - to sanction Israel for its illegal occupation, an occupation that has been backed by US political, diplomatic and financial power. Several US lawmakers wish to make any talk of a boycott of Israel illegal in the US. In this context, it is understandable that Oxfam America had to tread lightly.

Any link between the Johansson fiasco and the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign would bring Oxfam America into this toxic environment. Eventually, good sense prevailed and Johansson cut her ties to Oxfam.

Small as it may seem in the context of a long battle, the Johansson affair is one more piece of evidence that illegal Israeli actions in the occupied Palestinian territories are being increasingly held up to scrutiny. There is no longer impunity for those willing to associate themselves with it. Patience has run out and an honest debate on western support for Israel at all costs is now on the table.

This debate is better than silence, or than celebrity airbrushing of deep-seated problems.

Vijay Prashad is the Edward Said chair at the American University of Beirut

(c) 2014 Guardian Newspapers Limited.

React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
<1m ago RESEARCH AND MARKETS : Construction in the UAE - Key Trends and Opportunities to 2018
<1m ago Fitch Releases Report on Munson Healthcare Obligated Group, MI
1m ago HIGHBK RES : Highbank Comments on Landmark BC LNG News
1m ago BELDEN : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Creation of a Direct Financial Obligation or an Obligation under an Off-Balance Sheet Arrangement of a Registrant, Other Events, Financial Statements and Exhibits (form 8-K)
1m ago INVESTOR ALERT : Glancy Binkow & Goldberg LLP Announces An Expanded Class Period in the Shareholder Lawsuit Against Tesco PLC
2m ago CANYON GOLD : 10-K/A - Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.
2m agoDJU.S. Third-Quarter GDP Revised Up to 3.9% Growth -- 2nd Update
2m ago Hi-Tech Holiday Preview
2m ago Fitch Upgrades One and Affirms Two Classes of Madison Square 2004-1
3m ago JG WENTWORTH : J.G. WENTWORTH CO : Other Events, Financial Statements and Exhibits (form 8-K)
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
THALASSA : Issues Profit Warning On Contract Delays, Russia Sanctions
RETROSCREEN VIROLOGY : Full-Year Revenue To Fall On Influenza Pipeline Delays
KOOVS : Widens Half-Year Loss As Cost Of Sales Offset Revenue Growth
MANUTAN INTL : Acquisition telezhka, tilter for drums, stremyanka, transformer telescopic Manutan
LAKELAND : to Report Fiscal Third Quarter Financial Results and Conduct Conference Call
Most Read News
1d ago HERCULES OFFSHORE : to Present at Upcoming Investor Conferences
1d ago MOL GLOBAL : Deutsche Bank advises caution over Malaysia e-payment firm it helped list
1d ago GM PRESIDENT : U.S. economy holding up, other regions slowing or soft
1d agoDJAMERICAN AIRLINES : Waives Re-Scheduling Fee on Some Nov. 26 Flights
1d agoDJBOJ Minutes Show Some Members Against More Easing
Most recommended articles
2m agoDJU.S. Third-Quarter GDP Revised Up to 3.9% Growth -- 2nd Update
3m agoDJGold Edges Higher on Weak U.S. Consumer-Confidence Data
7m ago GOOGLE : United States says EU's Google case should not be politicised
15m agoDJBritish Insurer Aviva to Shutter U.S. Hedge-Fund Arm -- Update
29m agoDJSpotify's Revenue Rose in 2013, But Losses Continued - 2nd Update
Dynamic quotes  
ON
| OFF