Member access

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersVideosCalendar 

FCC - Federal Communications Commission : Duplication Alert: Broadband Pilot Projects

03/07/2014 | 01:44pm US/Eastern

January's IP Trials Order contained a provision to use USF dollars to fund rural broadband "experiments" designed to deliver robust, high-speed, scalable broadband service.  The language put out for comment on this new program potentially gives the FCC latitude to do any number of things in this space, including gigabit communities.

Exactly five days later, Congress spoke to this very same issue.  Included in the Agricultural Act of 2014 ("The Farm Bill") is a provision that allocates up to $50 million-$10 million per year for FY 2014-2018- to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to create a Rural Gigabit Network Pilot Program.  To be eligible for these funds, a provider must be able to build out "ultra-high-speed Internet service" within three years in rural areas that lack such service.   

I have raised a number of concerns about the FCC's new rural broadband experiments.  First, I worry how the new experiments will fit together with the high-cost universal service reforms that the FCC already adopted in 2011 and, despite my best efforts, I have not received an adequate explanation to date.  Second, as configured, these experiments could divert needed funds away from expanding broadband access for all Americans in favor of funding very high-capacity projects for a select few anchor institutions.  Third, I am very concerned about the ability of these experiments to succeed with one-time funding.  And now, I believe that these experiments could duplicate the Congressionally-mandated gigabit pilot program.  Instead of going down this path, the FCC should rethink the need for these experiments.

If the FCC does decide to press forward with its own rural broadband experiments, I will be looking to ensure that we abide by the following principles when deciding upon any final rules or approving any experiments:

1) No Duplication.  First, the FCC's experiments must accomplish something very different from the USDA's pilot program.  As I have said before, done well, rural broadband experiments might be useful to help us determine whether additional providers would be interested in serving consumers in rural America-particularly in the event that a current incumbent provider chooses not to participate in the universal service program in the future.  Unfortunately, January's Notice of Proposed Rulemaking seems to suggest that the FCC is more interested in funding a few higher-capacity broadband projects for a few institutions, which could be very similar to what the USDA will be doing.  Second, the FCC must not fund experiments in areas that are served or will be served by USDA's pilot program or existing providers.  Such duplication makes no sense and goes against our obligation to spend every consumer dollar as efficiently and effectively as possible.

2) Rationalize Spending.  In its Notice, the FCC contemplated spending between $50 - $100 million (or more) on its new experiments.  Given the passage of the Farm Bill, which authorizes $50 million for the USDA's pilot program, the FCC needs to take this significant funding into account and scale down our own budget accordingly.

3) Ensure Qualified Participants.  The Farm Bill requires that those participating in the USDA pilot program demonstrate that they are capable of providing service.  The FCC should do no less.  We must not dedicate limited funding to wishes and whims, but only to verifiable, concrete plans from companies that can actually build and operate a sustainable broadband network after the one-time FCC support ends-because it will end.  The FCC should not approve any scenario where a new network funded through the experiments will cease to operate unless continued dollars keep flowing from the Universal Service Fund after the program ends. 

4) Don't Zap Focus.  The FCC experiments have the potential to divert limited staff resources from a main priority: following through on transforming our high-cost universal service fund into a program that is sustainable in the 21st Century.  While I may not agree with all of the 2011 reforms, the high-cost programs account for $4.5 billion annually and require considerable attention.  Staff workshops, webinars, presentations, guidance and oversight will be needed to achieve success on any new experiments.  But these take significant time and staff hours. 

Our job at the Commission is to carry out the will and direction enacted by Congress.  Given the passage of the Farm Bill, we should consider ending our own rural broadband experiments and instead focus on supporting and learning from the USDA's Rural Gigabit Network Pilot Program.

distributed by
React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
1m ago MEDIA ADVISORY : Industry Minister James Moore to Announce Support for Quebec's Manufacturing Industry
3m ago BLACKSTONE/GSO SENIOR FLTG RT TERM FUND : Blackstone / GSO Closed-End Funds : Declare Monthly Distributions
3m agoDJCURRENCIES : Ruble Hits Fresh Lows Against Dollar After OPEC Decision
3m ago AK STEEL : Most active New York Stock Exchange-traded stocks
9m agoDJAirbus Trims Dassault Aviation Stake
10m agoDJFresenius Set to Pull Out of Bidding for Danone's Medical-Nutrition Business
11m ago PATHFINDER INCOME FUND : Middlefield Announces Completion of Extension for Pathfinder Income Fund
11m ago STRATEGIC GLOBAL INCOME FUND : — Distribution Characteristics for November 2014
11m ago GLOBAL HIGH INCOME FUND : — Distribution Characteristics for November 2014
12m agoDJRTL : Bertelsmann CFO Hartmann to Step Down Jan. 31 -- Update
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
DIXONS CARPHONE : Currys PC World stands poised for one order every second on Black Friday
AUGEAN : Chairman Buys 55,000 Shares (DIRECTOR DEALINGS)
MJ GLEESON : Expects Results To Beat Expectations On Strong Homes Unit
PROXAMA : In Final Stages For Proposed Aconite Acquisition (ALLISS)
MIRADA : New Commercial launch - Telefonica Peru
Most Read News
1d ago WHOLE FOODS MARKET : Jordan named president of Whole Foods’ Rockies division
1d ago GLENCORE : invests in Congo hydropower as solution to blackouts
1d ago SIMON PROPERTY : May Be Looking to Buy Macerich, Recent Transactions Indicate
1d ago MACERICH : 10 Must Reads for the CRE Industry Today (November 20, 2014)
46m ago Wall St. up for sixth straight week despite oil rout
Most recommended articles
2m agoDJCURRENCIES : Ruble Hits Fresh Lows Against Dollar After OPEC Decision
8m agoDJAirbus Trims Dassault Aviation Stake
9m agoDJFresenius Set to Pull Out of Bidding for Danone's Medical-Nutrition Business
11m agoDJRTL : Bertelsmann CFO Hartmann to Step Down Jan. 31 -- Update
17m ago Fresenius set to walk away from Danone unit - sources
Dynamic quotes  
ON
| OFF