Member access

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersVideosCalendar 

Health Insurers Tumble on Negative Medicare Advantage Rate Proposal

02/19/2013 | 02:14pm US/Eastern

--Health-insurance stocks slide after government proposes worse-than-expected Medicare Advantage rates

--Humana falls the most among big companies, reflecting heavy Medicare focus

--Language in proposal may leave door open for favorable changes, analysts say

(Adds analyst, government and industry comments.)

 
   By Jon Kamp 
 

Shares of Humana Inc. (>> Humana Inc.) and other major health insurers tumbled Tuesday following an unfavorable government proposal for Medicare Advantage rates in 2014 that analysts said came in worse than expected.

The late-Friday proposal is open to outside comments until March 1, ahead of a final announcement due April 1, so there is time for the industry to lobby for less pressure on rates. Insurers see Medicare Advantage--their version of the government health plan for seniors--as a key growth area, but ramping up presence there means taking on exposure to government payment decisions.

The new proposal from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services is "sharply unfavorable" and "significantly worse than expected," Goldman Sachs analyst Matthew Borsch said in a note to investors.

There are several moving parts in the complicated proposal, and different companies could be affected in different ways depending on the people they serve and the quality ratings their plans achieve. Nevertheless, some analysts calculated rates declining by a mid-single-digit rate next year, steeper than they expected.

Humana came to a similar conclusion while noting it previously expected that rates would be "flat to slightly down" next year. Humana management recently expressed confidence about growing next year, but that was based on the company's prior rate assumptions.

Following the worse-than-expected proposal, "Humana is closely analyzing all operational avenues available to address those preliminary rates and the related impact upon the company's ability to grow both its Medicare membership and its earnings for 2014," the company said in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing.

Humana shares tumbled 6.4% to $73.01 in recent trading. The Louisville, Ky., insurer gets more than half its profits from Medicare Advantage, outpacing its more diversified, large managed-care peers, according to Raymond James analyst Michael Baker.

But the industry in general has been bulking up in Medicare-based plans, latching onto a growing market as baby boomers age. Elsewhere in the sector, UnitedHealth Group Inc. (>> UnitedHealth Group Inc.) recently traded down 1.7%, Cigna Corp. (>> CIGNA Corporation) declined 1.5%, Aetna Inc. (>> Aetna Inc.) fell 1.3% and WellPoint Inc. (>> WellPoint, Inc.) traded off 0.2%.

Among smaller firms with heavy Medicare links, Universal American Corp. (>> Universal American Corporation) sank 6.3% to $9.21, while WellCare Health Plans Inc. (>> WellCare Health Plans, Inc.) declined 2.1% to $58.99.

Industry group America's Health Insurance Plans blasted the proposal, saying it adds to payment cuts and tax pressure already coming from the health-care overhaul law. These changes together will reduce Medicare Advantage payments next year by more than 8%, or about $11 billion, AHIP estimated.

"Washington cannot tax and cut Medicare Advantage this much and not expect seniors to be harmed," said Karen Ignagni, AHIP's president and chief executive, in a statement.

The industry has time to lobby for less-bruising changes, though, and analysts suggested language in the government's proposal leaves some wiggle room.

"We appreciate that plans are facing several legislatively mandated changes affecting payment for 2014, and this may present challenges for plans," CMS said in a 199-page notice highlighting planned rate changes. "We solicit comment on suggestions to address these challenges within the parameters of current law."

Citigroup analyst Carl McDonald called this a "major takeaway," while saying it's highly probable that rates won't turn out as bad as suggested. As it stands, he called the current proposal "really, really bad."

Other analysts also picked out some morsels that could brighten an initially gloomy picture. J.P. Morgan analyst Justin Lake suggested insurers were bruised early Tuesday by worries they had little room to change benefits to adjust for disappointing rates. But he suggested a more favorable read that gives companies some benefit flexibility.

Stifel Nicolaus analyst Thomas Carroll noted, meantime, that most private-sector Medicare plans did well despite a steep cut in 2010. While the managed-care plans have some work to do, "we do not believe there will be a material impact to margins," Mr. Carroll said.

Write to Jon Kamp at jon.kamp@dowjones.com

Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires

React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
<1m ago PLANET : hoes Announces Special Comfortable Shoes That Make Great Last-minute Gifts
8m ago ROBYG : Current Report no 88 - Registration of series L bonds with the National Depository for Securities
14m ago NESTE OIL : to revise its full-year 2014 guidance
14m ago After odyssey to Pennsylvania, lost dog returns home to High Point
28m ago SPIRIT AIRLINES : others trim back for winter earlier than usual
37m ago NATIONWIDE CCDS CORE CAPITAL DEFERRED SHS MIN 250 CCDS : Spending too food and drink much on your for Christmas? ; Have you bitten off more than you can chew when it comes to spending on Christmas dinner,...
37m ago JOHN WOOD : Oil-collapse claims 'over the top', expert says
37m ago ECB's Constancio sees negative inflation rate in months ahead - magazine
38m ago ROYAL MAIL : VIP's stamp of approval ; NORTH TODAY
38m ago MICHELIN CGDE : And the winner is... ; The best restaurants in our region
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
DENDREON : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Change in Directors or Principal Officers, Other Events, Financial Statements and Exhibits (form 8-K)
DIXONS CARPHONE : *exane bnp raises dixons carphone price target to 510 (450) pence - 'outperform'
BERKELEY MINERAL RESOURCES : Obsidian IR
NATURE : Warns 2014 Results To Be "Materially" Below Market View
FINISH LINE : Reports Third Quarter Fiscal Year 2015 Results
Most Read News
1h ago Obama vows U.S. response to North Korea over Sony cyberattack
1d ago SYSCO : Poised to Complete US Foods Deal (Report)
1d ago U.S. labor agency files complaints against McDonald's
1d agoDJBank of Nova Scotia to Buy Citigroup Retail, Commercial Operations in Peru
1d ago KMC KUEI MENG : CNET Exclusive Debut of Leawo Video Converter Ultimate Releases on 18th
Most recommended articles
37m ago ECB's Constancio sees negative inflation rate in months ahead - magazine
1h ago Obama vows U.S. response to North Korea over Sony cyberattack
1h ago Japan, South Korea condemn Sony hack; Chinese paper says movie is senseless
1d ago Three air-bag accidents at Boeing plant lead to extra safety measures
1d ago U.S. judge rejects HP settlement in Autonomy shareholder case
Dynamic quotes  
ON
| OFF