Member access

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersVideosCalendar 

Herbalife : A Ponzi scheme scandal

04/03/2013 | 10:09am US/Eastern

Herbalife, a company founded in 1980 and specialized in the sale of nutrition, weight management and skin-care products, is currently at the heart of a scandal which reminds us the Madoff case.

The firm’s business is based on a MLM system (Multi Level Marketing), the same which made the success of Tupperware. The principle is easy to understand: distributors are recruited among the general public, then these people sell their products to their families and friends and hire them, as well, as resellers. They have to spend 400 dollars to buy a first product pack in order to start their activity, according to a distributors interviewed by the Wall Street Journal.

Thus, the group is accused to make the majority of its sales through the recruitment of new staff, and not thanks to the sale of slimming products, what would make Herbalife’s activity a Ponzi scheme.

William Ackman, founder of the highly successful investment fund Pershing Square, has protested in December 2012 against the practices of the company and announced he had short sold for the modest sum of one billion dollars, saying the actual value of the Herbalife’s share was zero dollar. Indeed, we have learned in the New York Post the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) might have started a “law-enforcement investigation” into Herbalife (however the firm asked a correction to the journal and denies the information). Mr. Ackman has defended its position in a 342 slides oral presentation in Manhattan: he affirms that Herbalife sells its nutritional powder, which represents 27% of sales, twice the competitors’ price in average and its multivitamins, the triple. He adds that these products have no competitive advantage, R&D expenditures being very low. Thus, it is unlikely that the firm manages to sell its products to actual customers, and that revenues may come in major portion from purchases made by new distributors.

Carl Icahn, Bill Ackman’s historic adversary with whom he has had several financial disagreement, announced on 14th February, after having heavily argued with Ackman on U.S. medias, that he has invested in 13% of Herbalife’s capital. Hard blow for Bill Ackman, which sees the share skyrockets and which is now in a very bad situation with its billion dollars short sell.

Icahn is not the only one to support Herbalife and to contradict the Persing Square’s boss. One of the Bronte Capital’s managers issued a note in January in order to discredit the William Ackman’s theory: “Bill Ackman’s thesis is the most easily falsified bear-thesis I have seen from a major hedge fund ever”. The editor said he went visiting an Herbalife’s nutrition club in Queens and realized that most customers were as well distributors, but principally in order to get a 25 percent discount on products they buy. Above all, he notes while discussing with customers and owners of the club the obvious presence of a community’s spirit which helps users in their efforts to lose weight. He adds that the strength and the wideness of the community are possible thanks to the Multi Level Marketing.

This Bronte Capital’s manager, contracts the arguments of Mr. Ackman point by point:

- Competitive advantage, absent according to the Mr. Ackman’s thesis would be, actually, the community support provided by Herbalife’s products: “Herbalife is sold with a community support mechanism. In Central Park anyone can go and have a run. It is free. It costs you $20 an hour if you exercise with a personal trainer”, the value of Herbalife’s products would come therefore from the support provided by the community.

- Ackman notes the lack of advertising spending and therefore the incapacity to maintain such prices. The editor responds: “Herbalife has the best advertising possible – word of mouth”.
 
- The main argument of Bill Ackman is that the real Herbalife product is not a physical item, but actually a business opportunity proposed to customers who appear to be, in fine, distributors. Its detractor agrees with him that many customers are resellers, but also states that they clearly are consumers of the product, as he notes in the club visited in Queens.

The note concludes: “Bill Ackman (…) bet over a billion dollars on a short position without checking the facts”. Mr. Ackman did not go see what was happening on the ground, but it seems a little bit pretentious to claim to have invalidated the Ackman’s theory using as argument an example of a single Herbalife’s point of sale. Nobody can confirm that the findings identified in the club, are true everywhere else.

Anyway, it is very difficult to predict the outcome of the Herbalife’s case. It is therefore best to stay away from this security before we get answers to our questions. Indeed, only convinced investors remain committed in the stock, generating as a consequence an extreme tension on the share. One day or another, one of our two investors will withdraw its position, causing a collapse or a surge in prices, depending on the case.

Herbalife' stock chart (candles in daily data):



Mr. Ackman will be named winner in case of a decision of the Federal Trade Commission defining the Herbalife’s activity as illegal. Only problem for Ackman: the FTC did not want to confirm that an investigation was actually ongoing, without refuting. As shown by the graphic of the Herbalife’s stock, prices are forming a configuration in triangle which ends in mid-April. It seems likely that, in the absence of a decision from the institution or new revelation, the scandal gradually disappears by itself, sellers lose hope and buyers strengthen sending back prices towards new annual highs, even historical records.


© 4-traders.com 2013
React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
1m ago SKANSKA : sells commercial building in Seattle, USA, for USD 70 M, about SEK 475 M
1m ago FORMPIPE SOFTWARE : receives order from a Danish authority worth SEK 2.2 million
2m ago CENTRAL BANK OF RUSSIA : Terms and Conditions of Fixed-Rate Secured Loan Operations
2m ago WARTSILA ABP : Wärtsilä supplies 11 industrial power plants for EUROCEMENT Group
2m ago BUDIMEX : signed a contract with EDF Polska
2m ago ESCAP ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMISSION FOR ASIA AN : and Germany strengthen partnership in early warning for coastal hazards
2m ago BUDIMEX : is the best construction company listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange
2m ago PURE WAFER : Production To Take Hit As Swansea Facility Damaged By Fire
2m ago WANDISCO : Wins USD475,000 Big Data Contract With Dunnhumby
3m ago WOODSPEEN TRAINING GROUP PLC - Withdrawal and Notice of AGM
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
MATTEL : Boys and girls spoilt for choice
CIVITAS SOLUTIONS : Posts Fourth Quarter and Annual Results
MORPHOSYS : Announces Clinical Milestone in Oncology Program
NEFF : Supports Swakop Land Grabbers
AMN HEALTHCARE SERVICES : to Purchase Onward Healthcare, Locum Leaders and Medefis
Most Read News
1d ago GOODMAN : GMG distribution for the six months ending 31 December 2014
1d agoDJBANK OF EAST ASIA : Thomas Kwok Conviction Won't Impact Company
1d ago SMARTAC CHINA : 22 Dec 2014Announcements and Notices - Voluntary Announcement in Respect of Signing of Wi-fi installation and Post-installation Maintenance and Operation Agreement
1d ago SONY : Kevin Hart to host 'Saturday Night Live' Jan. 17
1d ago INDOOR SKYDIVE AUSTRALIA : ASX:IDZ) Perth Development Application Lodged
Most recommended articles
4m agoDJNCONDEZI ENERGY TO RAISE GBP3.4 MILLION VIA 1 : 4 Open Offer/5.78P
6m ago Airbus to sue Skymark in UK court over canceled A380 contract
9m ago Kingfisher sells stake in B&Q China business for $219 mln
11m agoDJBrent Rebounds Back Above $62
16m agoDJFLYBE : Signs 8.5 Year Pact with Airbus Defence and Space
Dynamic quotes  
ON
| OFF