Log in
Login
Password
Remember
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Settings
Settings
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  News

News

Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesInterest RatesHot NewsMost Read NewsRecomm.Business LeadersCalendar 
The feature you requested does not exist. However, we suggest the following feature:

Brexit baffled punters, pundits and fund managers to the very end

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
0
06/25/2016 | 07:06am CEST
A trader from BGC, a global brokerage company in London's Canary Wharf financial centre reacts during trading

Nearly everyone, from London gamblers to U.S. money managers got it wrong. Britain's vote to leave the European Union shocked pundits, investors and politicians alike, underscoring the inherent difficulty of forecasting such rare events.

   On PredictIt, an online political events betting site operated by Victoria University in Wellington, New Zealand and U.S.-based partners, bettors had the probability of a “leave” camp win at just 16 percent on Thursday as British polls closed. Within four hours of the vote count, that had shot to 90 percent.

   The dramatic reversal caught many investors flat footed and showed how they have trouble hedging against such shocks even with the help of such tools as exchange-traded funds or computer algorithms designed to capture an electorate's social media vibe, economists, pollsters and fund managers said on Friday.

Predicting the outcome of Thursday's referendum was harder than that of a national election because there was virtually no historical data to draw on, said David Rothschild, an economist at Microsoft Research. He said pollsters also did not pay enough attention to working class and less educated voters.

The city of Sunderland, for example, home to Britain's largest car factory and considered a bellwether of the sentiment among blue-collar voters, surprised with the strength of its support for EU departure and when the result came among the first that night it sent the pound reeling.

    Rothschild, who forecast Britain would vote to remain in the bloc it joined in 1973, had a lot of company.

A person familiar with the campaign's monitoring by the U.S. intelligence agencies admitted that they were befuddled by the vote's outcome." We're all scratching our heads."

By mid-week, a rise in demand for S&P 500 put options was indicating that more and more investors were either betting on a market drop or hedging themselves against such a scenario, said David Jilek, chief investment strategist at Gateway Investment Advisers.

   Yet while opinion polls went back and forth and kept indicating a close vote, betting odds consistently favored the "remain" camp. And since odds makers fared better than pollsters in predicting the results of the last general election and the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, the 52-48 percent victory for the "leave" campaign to leave was such a shock.

THROUGH THE ROOF

Global stock markets and the British pound tumbled on Friday after a wild election night ride.

    "All through Thursday the big bets had come in favor of "remain" but as the clock ticked toward midnight the most extraordinary reversal got underway," said David Williams, a spokesman for betting firm Ladbrokes. "In the end we've managed our book well enough to make a few quid but the real story for the bookies was just how enormous the turnover was," he said.

"Never before in our 130-year history have we known a night when betting went through the roof like this."

    Betfair, a betting exchange, said the implied probability of a remain vote was 94 percent right up until the polls closed, but that changed dramatically in the wee hours of Friday when early results started coming in.

“At one point after the Sunderland result had been announced, there was more than £5-10k being traded per second on the market, which is absolutely huge,” said Naomi Totten, a spokeswoman for Betfair. (graphic: http://tmsnrt.rs/28SKhzZ)

One theory is that some of the more affluent punters were staunch supporters of the "remain" campaign and bet on it to win, according to two gambling analysts. Since EU supporters bet more money than those from the "leave" camp, that skewed the odds and public perceptions about the likely outcome, said the analysts, who did not want to be named because they were not authorized to speak about betting trends.

    Money managers, meanwhile, may be kicking themselves for failing to deploy simple hedging strategies. Charles Reinhard, head of portfolio strategy at MainStay Investments, said building up cash or buying more stable, dividend-paying stocks could have dampened Friday's stock market shock wave.

    But Don Steinbrugge, managing partner at Agecroft Partners, said hedge fund managers are rewarded for beating the market and face heavy redemptions from clients if they are cautious and take large cash positions.

    "They want you to beat the market through stock selection," he said.

    Rothschild, who also is a fellow at Columbia University’s Applied Statistics Center, said he expected forecasting to improve with a transition from polls using small, random representative samples to large Internet-based ones with rich demographic data.

    "If I have one million respondents with a large amount demographic data, I should be able to predict outcomes better, or I'm not a very good statistician," he said.    

(Reporting By Tim McLaughlin; Additional reporting by Mark Hosenball; Editing by Tomasz Janowski)

By Tim McLaughlin

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
0
React to this article
Latest news
Date Title
07:06a Brexit baffled punters, pundits and fund managers to the very end
07:03a Sports schedule for Sunday, June 26
07:01a GREENS EUROPEAN FREE ALLIANCE IN EUROPEA : UK referendum - European partners must work together to deliver decisive response to UK vote
07:01a GREENS EUROPEAN FREE ALLIANCE IN EUROPEA : EU energy rules - Parliament calls for greater ambition ahead of upcoming review
07:01a GREENS EUROPEAN FREE ALLIANCE IN EUROPEA : Tax avoidance - Minimalist new EU law shows EU governments not taking problem seriously
06:26a CMA MISSES THE MARK : Remedies to fuel greater complexity in domestic energy market
06:24a BAIDU : China to regulate search results following man's death
06:16a CENTRAL PEOPLE GOVERNMENT OF PEOPLE RE : Big expectations for Davos Forum
05:50a Khang & Khang LLP Announces the Filing of a Securities Class Action Lawsuit against Chiasma, Inc. and Reminds Investors with Losses to Contact the Firm
05:49a BRIEF : Aetna, Humana Extend Acquisition Deadline
Latest news
Advertisement
Hot News 
ELECTRO RENT : Platinum Equity Increases Electro Rent Purchase Price Offer to $15.50 Per Share
Incipio Group to Acquire Skullcandy; Create Leading Technology, Creative Culture and Mobile Lifestyle Company
FINISH LINE : Reports First Quarter Fiscal Year 2017 Results
LSL PROPERTY SERVICES : May 16 Buy-to-Let Index
B&M EUROPEAN VALUE RETAIL : Annual Report and Accounts 2016
Most Read News
06/24 'Investing for good' gains appeal amid rocky tech startup market
Most recommended articles
06/24 LOTTE CHEMICAL : chairman defeats brother's challenge, retains control at AGM
06/24 China-backed AIIB approves fund to support members for project preparation
06/24DJJOACHIM FABER : Deutsche Börse, LSE to Push Ahead with Merger Despite 'Brexit' Vote--Update
06/24DJDEUTSCHE BOERSE : Correction to Deutsche Börse, LSE to Push Ahead with Merger Despite 'Brexit' Vote
06/24DJEnergy Transfer Can Escape Williams Takeover, Judge Rules -- 2nd Update