Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Xetra  >  Allianz    ALV   DE0008404005

Mes dernières consult.
Most popular
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsofficial PublicationsSector newsTweets
OFFRE ETE Zonebourse : Jusqu'à 6 mois offerts sur tous les portefeuilles

Allianz : Taxpayers will need to subsidise Sydney stadium overhauls, documents reveal

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
06/11/2018 | 09:11pm CEST

The controversial redevelopments of the Allianz stadium at Moore Park and the ANZ stadium at Homebush will deliver negative returns on the New South Wales government’s investment, according to business cases made public today.

This means taxpayers will need to subsidise the stadiums over their life cycle, the documents show.

The analysis also reveals that the financial cases are strongly dependent on increasing the number of major events at Allianz, which runs the risk of cannibalising the revenues of the stadium at Homebush, currently the preferred venue for major events such as finals and internationals.

• Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

The cost-benefit analysis relates only to the financial cost-benefit. Both reports, by KPMG, argue that they will greatly enhance the spectator experience at the venue and provide broader economic and social benefit.

The redevelopment of the stadiums in Sydney has been highly contentious after the premier, Gladys Berejiklian, dumped a plan by her predecessor, Mike Baird, to spend $1.6bn mainly on upgrading facilities in Sydney’s west.

At one stage the likely bill reached $2.5bn but the government has now agreed to spend $2.3bn on its stadium plans, including replacing Allianz in Sydney’s east with a 40,000-45,000-seat stadium at a cost of $729m. Allianz will be rebuilt first. The sum of $810m will then be spent on ANZ at Homebush to make it a rectangular field. There are additional costs plus a new stadium at Parramatta which make up the total spend.

The new policy followed intensive lobbying of the sports minister, Stuart Ayres, by the Sydney Cricket and Sports Ground Trust, which includes high-profile figures such as broadcaster Alan Jones, businessman Tony Shepherd, former News Ltd CEO John Hartigan and businesswoman Katie Page.

Page’s husband, Gerry Harvey, together with John Singleton, have the lease on the Entertainment Quarter next door to the football and cricket grounds, and are also planning a major redevelopment.

The Trust argued that Allianz, also known as the Sydney Football Stadium, is in urgent need of replacement because it is in breach of fire and safety requirements.

But the NSW opposition has queried both the size and urgency of the upgrade and whether spending on sports stadiums is the right priority.

The government has been resisting making the business cases public but relented last week after the NSW upper house censured the government’s leader in the chamber.

The release of a separate report on the business case for moving the Powerhouse Museum to Parramatta is still being negotiated. It could be made public later in the week.

The KPMG report on Allianz shows four options were considered: a base case, involving capital spending $341m to address the fire and safety concerns, versus two different rebuilds costed at between $750m-$775m and an extensive refurbishment which was $714m. The government has opted for a knockdown and rebuild at a cost of $729m.

The analysis acknowledges that the event calendar is the key driver of a venue’s ability to generate revenue and a strong financial performance.

The Allianz rebuild options would attract more NRL games and also some rugby union games to Moore Park, KPMG says.

But the opposition’s sports spokeswoman, Linda Voltz, said there was a real risk the growth at Allianz will come at the expense of ANZ.

The Greens MLC David Shoebridge said there should be common management of both stadiums “ so they don’t end up fighting each other for the same crowd”.

The base case for Allianz, which involves fixing only the safety issues, assumes 10 NRL games will be played at Allianz and no Wallabies games and international rugby league. But if the stadium is knocked down and rebuilt, KPMG says Allianz can expect to host 16 NRL games and up to 4 Wallabies games.

Despite the forecast increased use, all of the options for Allianz were negative on a cost-benefit analysis, with the rebuilds scoring 0.93, compared to refurbishment which scored 0.62. A score of 1.0 or better indicates a positive cost-benefit.

Labor’s sports spokeswoman, Linda Voltz, said the base case for Allianz was made to appear worse than it was because there were fewer NRL games included than the 13 games on average. But KPMG said this was justified due to the poor and declining facilities at Allianz.

The business case for the redevelopment of the Olympic stadium also shows negative cost-benefit. The government’s preferred option of a refurbishment and extension of the roof at a cost of $810m, shows a cost benefit of 0.8. The two rebuild options scored better in the cost benefit analysis (0.91 and 0.89) but involved much bigger capital spending of either $1.29bn or $1.33bn.

“My principal concern is that this report focusses on the value to stakeholders – the sporting bodies, the trust and the Stadium Australia,” Shoebridge said. “The returns to the public are rated a distant second.”

Copyright © 2018 theguardian.com. All rights reserved., source Guardian Online

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on ALLIANZ
12:29pALLIANZ : Nephila Climate, Allianz complete transactions for 228MW Lal Lal wind ..
12:22pALLIANZ : denies report on plan to cut 5,000 jobs in Germany
10:13aALLIANZ : Pan-European Insurance Forum appoints Thomas Buberl of AXA as Chair
06/19ALLIANZ SE : Release according to Article 40, Section 1 of the WpHG [the German ..
06/19EULER HERMES OIL PRICE SCENARIOS : Look beyond geopolitics
06/18EXCLUSIVE : KKR close to signing deal for Altice's telecom towers - sources
06/14ENCOURAGING FUTURE GENERATIONS : Never Too Young, Never Too Old
06/13ALLIANZ SE : Release according to Article 41 of the WpHG [the German Securities ..
06/12FIFA WORLD CUP 2018 : Ready to Play
More news
News from SeekingAlpha
06/20Altice Europe in ?2.5B deal to sell tower stakes in France, Portugal 
06/18REUTERS : KKR near deal for stake in Altice towers 
06/18DIVIDEND PORTFOLIO REVIEW : New Dividend Record 
06/08ADMIRAL : 5.9% Yield Is Attractive For Income Investors 
05/31German Stocks For Dividend Growth Investing 
Financials (€)
Sales 2018 120 B
EBIT 2018 11 368 M
Net income 2018 7 572 M
Debt 2018 -
Yield 2018 4,93%
P/E ratio 2018 10,07
P/E ratio 2019 9,49
Capi. / Sales 2018 0,63x
Capi. / Sales 2019 0,61x
Capitalization 75 907 M
Duration : Period :
Allianz Technical Analysis Chart | ALV | DE0008404005 | 4-Traders
Technical analysis trends ALLIANZ
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 32
Average target price 213 €
Spread / Average Target 21%
EPS Revisions
Oliver Bäte Chief Executive Officer
Michael Diekmann Chairman-Supervisory Board
Christof Mascher Chief Operating Officer
Giulio Terzariol Chief Financial Officer
Rolf Zimmermann Vice Chairman-Supervisory Board
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
ALLIANZ-8.14%87 722
CHUBB LTD-11.28%60 293