Event ID: 2013178
Event Title: Qatar Navigation MMCID QNNS QNB Financial Services
Date: April 19, 2023
Audio Duration: 00:28:44
Executives:
Akram Iswaisi - Executive Vice President, Finance & Investments
Sami Shtayyeh - Vice President, Financial Planning & Analysis
Operator:Hello and welcome to the Milaha Conference Call. I would like to advise all participants that this call is being recorded. Thank you. I'd now like to welcome Bobby Sarkar to begin the conference. Bobby, over to you.
Bobby Sarkar:Thank you, Gavin. Hi. Hello, everyone. This is Bobby Sarkar, head of research at QNB Financial Services. I want to welcome everyone to Milaha's First Quarter 2023 Results Conference Call. So, on this call we have Akram Iswaisi, who is the EVP of Finance Investment, and Sami Shtayyeh, who's the VP of Financial Planning and Analysis. So, we will conduct this conference with the management first, reviewing the company's results followed by a Q&A.
I would like to turn the call over now to Akram. Akram, please go ahead.
Akram Iswaisi: Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you everyone for joining Milaha's Q1 2023 Earnings Call and your interest in our company. Let me start by just saying that we had a very good Q1, especially when considering the steep decline in container shipping rates and the very difficult macro environment. However, we were able to remain focused on growing the business and focused on growing a profitable business and at the same time eliminate unneeded costs to improve our bottom line. We'll follow along the same lines as previous calls. I will be starting with our consolidated financial results and then we'll go through our various segments before turning it over to Sami to go over our outlook for the remainder of the year. And as usual, we will end the call with a Q&A.
The key highlights of our financial results. Milaha's operating revenues came in at QR 766 million for the first quarter of 2023 compared with QR 913 million for the same period in 2022, for a decrease of 16%. Operating profit came in at QR 210 million for the first quarter of 2023 compared with QR 194 million for the same period in 2022, for an increase of 8%. Net profit for the first quarter of 2023 was QR 363 million compared with QR 360 million for the same period in 2022, for an increase of 1%. And lastly, our earnings per share remained flat at QR 0.32 for the first quarter of 2023 and for the same period in 2022.
Now moving on to our segments. Maritime & Logistics, the big storyline in Maritime & Logistics has to do with the decline in container shipping rates, which we benefited from for the past two years when they hit record highs. We essentially began to see rates plummet towards the end of last year and that had a large negative impact on our Container Shipping segment. And of course, overall revenue dropped by 33% or QR 120 million as a result. Expenses came down by QR 57 million with most of that tied to the drop in container shipping. Overall, we ended the year with a net profit down QR 64 million or 73% versus last year.
- 1 -
With respect to Offshore. Offshore continued its growth trajectory with operating revenue | |
growing by 6% or QR 19 million versus the same period in 2022. This was driven by increased | |
utilization of key assets and additional diving-related projects which more than offset a drop in | |
third-partychartered-in vessels' income. Lower chartered-in costs related to the drop in revenue | |
and the one-off provision reversal drove a QR 29 million decrease in expenses versus the same | |
period in 2022. The net income result was year-over-year growth of QR 53 million or 627%. | |
As for Gas & Petrochem, we recorded an 8% increase in revenue with our FSO that was | |
employed in mid-2022, offsetting loss revenue from our divestment last year from the last gas | |
carrier. That divestment similarly contributed to lowering our expenses, which came down by | |
QR 5 million. At the non-operating level, income decreased by QR 18 million mainly as a result | |
of lower income from our associates, and the net profit of the segment ended down QR 8 million | |
or 5% versus the same period last year. | |
In our Trading segment, we were able to reduce bottom line losses by QR 5 million versus the | |
same period in 2022 by selling more marine-related and heavy equipment and improving | |
margins. And lastly, capital on the investment side, revenue decreased by QR 3 million with | |
lower dividend income offsetting higher fixed offsetting...being offset by higher fixed deposits | |
and other income. And in real estate, revenue remained flat with the same period last year and | |
on the expense side, we had a QR 16 million in lower bad debt provisions last year. All of which | |
resulted in overall net profit growth of QR 18 million or 17% versus the same period last year. | |
And that wraps up the segments and I will now turn it over to Sami to discuss our outlook for | |
the rest of the year. | |
Sami Shtayyeh: | Thank you, Akram. Starting with Maritime & Logistics. On the container shipping side, Q1 |
reflected the large container shipping rate drop and we expect that to hold for the rest of the | |
year. In logistics, we expect to slow down in the second quarter of the year but expect an uptick | |
during the second half of 2023. In offshore, on both the support vessels and services side as | |
well as the harbor side, we expect to see continued growth particularly longer term with all the | |
expansion in Qatar's oil and gas industry. | |
In Gas & Petrochem, overall, we expect limited volatility due to the long-term nature of | |
contracts we have in most business units. Our VLGC joint venture is the exception where | |
performance is difficult to predict due to volatile spot prices. In trading, we're going to continue | |
to work on profitable growth and margin improvement. And lastly, capital, our focus will | |
continue to be on yield enhancement. | |
And with that operator, we'll now open up for questions. | |
Operator: | If you wish to ask a question, please press star followed by one on your telephone and wait for |
your name to be announced. That is star one if you wish to ask the question. And your first | |
question comes from the line of Lee Beswick of QNB. Your line is open. | |
Lee Beswick: | Hi, yes, thanks for the presentation. Just a question on the balance sheet and dividend as well. |
The balance sheet is now extremely strong and it's probably...I think now it's probably fair to | |
label it inefficient. You're carrying net cash of QR 700 million. There's absolutely no need for | |
you to do that at all. So, the question sort of turns to the dividend and the payout ratio. The | |
payout ratio is simply too low. You know you should double it minimum. You used to carry a | |
payout ratio of 50 to 60%. I don't know why that changed. It's now down at 40%. So, the | |
question is why...what are you doing with the money? Because otherwise, you're just collecting |
- 2 -
cash on a balance sheet for no reason, you've got too much capital. I don't...unless there's some | |
massive growth out there which you're going to tell me about. Your payout ratio is frighteningly | |
low and very, very inefficient. | |
Akram Iswaisi: | Okay. Thank you very much for that question. Now, some of that cash that you are seeing is |
cash that is parked for redeployment because as I've mentioned in previous calls, we are | |
basically, we've liquidated certain positions and put some of that cash in deposits and we're | |
transitioning. So, we have a new strategy for the investment portfolio, and so that cash is | |
essentially the majority of it has to do with the investment portfolio. So, that's one thing. | |
The second thing is you've noticed that as an organization, we have been working on building | |
up some of the core activities like offshore and you've seen a significant improvement in the | |
offshore operating activities. There's a significant number of contracts that we have in the | |
pipeline right now that we are looking at, and these require significant CapEx commitment. | |
And so, there is a significant growth plan on the offshore side. And I have also mentioned...and | |
these are again, these are capital-intensive investments. We are looking at acquiring more assets | |
to be able to satisfy the local demand, which is substantial. At the same, mentioned on previous | |
calls, that we are looking to invest again in new segments like FSOs, FPSOs, and shuttle tankers. | |
And again, these are large CapEx investments. Now, that cash, as I mentioned, is earmarked | |
for the investment portfolio as well as to support some of these new investment programs in | |
our core business. | |
Lee Beswick: | Okay. So can you talk about if this...some of this cash is earmarked for future CapEx, what the |
return on capital and return on the equity you're going to generate out of these businesses | |
because I would suggest once again you still...I don't know how well, how much are you going | |
to spend on CapEx, I suppose as a question. But this company has consistently generated a | |
single-digit return. You have never pushed it into the double digits ever. So, what kind of returns | |
are you going to generate off this CapEx investment? | |
Akram Iswaisi: | Honestly, we don't provide guidance on that kind of return, but we are looking at a double-digit |
return. If you look at the offshore business in general, it has changed significantly. And it's | |
Halul or offshore for the first time in a long time, it's actually quite profitable and much more | |
efficient. And the oil and gas market is hot and robust right now. So again, the returns that we're | |
targeting in that segment are double-digit returns. | |
Lee Beswick: | Just in that segment, the other segments, it's less than double digits as it always is. There's |
always a segment doing well. There's always a segment doing badly. So, how do you generate | |
those? That's the whole... | |
Akram Iswaisi: | But that is the nature of the business. Invest in...when you invest in tanker business and |
container shipping that is the nature of the business. And this is across...if you look at the major | |
liners, they've struggled to make money for a long, long time. The past two or three years is | |
when those mainliners and container shipping companies started making money. So, if you look | |
at container shipping and the tanker business in general, it is a cyclical business. If you look at | |
the logistics business, it is a thin-margin business. And so, cyclicality is basically part of | |
shipping and logistics. But in the portfolio... | |
Lee Beswick: | Yes, I completely agree. |
Akram Iswaisi: | Okay. And the portfolio that we've got is a sustainable portfolio and this is why we have been |
able to consistently pay dividends. And so, you look at the container shipping the past two years |
- 3 -
we've done exceptionally well because the market has done exceptionally well. Containership | |
in the first quarter hasn't done well, but however, we are looking to grow that business. This is | |
the right time to start acquiring more tonnage. We do have plans to expand our network, but | |
again, if you look at our business, it is a portfolio of different businesses that complement each | |
other. And so again, container shipping, tankers, and shipping in general, these are cyclical | |
segments. | |
Lee Beswick: | Yes, I completely accept that, that is 100% true. It's still the fact that if I look at the last 10 years |
of navigation and you have your peak ROE return on equity is 8%, it suggests that you have an | |
issue with the way that the capital is deployed and maybe that is too much. In my opinion, and | |
I may be wrong, but you may have a different opinion, but it certainly seems that there's too | |
much capital in the business and therefore actually running down the capital and running the | |
business with a lower level of capital relative to what you're generating, and part of the way to | |
do that is through increase. Dividends is actually what the business needs to generate a decent | |
return because a peak ROE of 8% is pretty low. | |
Akram Iswaisi: | If you see our story this quarter, it's quite promising. You see some of those segments which |
have struggled for a while are actually beginning to deliver better results and better | |
performance. And so. we are optimistic about the future. There's a strong plan to...have to grow | |
the business and again, you have to rejuvenate the fleet, you have to continue...as an asset- | |
heavy company, we have to continue to invest in assets and this is where our revenue is going | |
to come from. So, fundamentally, we are aligned on the fact that the business needs to grow | |
and you're beginning to see some of that in Q1 where we're beginning to turn some of these | |
businesses around. And we have for example, trading is beginning to become profitable, | |
offshore again, multiple earnings calls. I've heard comments about offshore and we said, listen | |
give us some time, we'll show you what we can deliver, and we've been able to do that. So, I | |
know for a fact that there's a large CapEx program coming up and we are confident that we will | |
continue to deliver shareholder value. Milaha is a stable company and we've been able to | |
weather the storm through various cycles. | |
Lee Beswick: | Okay, I await the 10% or more ROE return on equity for four straight quarters in a row. |
Akram Iswaisi: | We'll put it as a target. |
Operator: | Your next question comes from Mustafa Aamer from Al Rayan Investment. Your line is open. |
Mustafa Aamer: | Hello, gentlemen, thank you for the presentation. Just wondering on the share of associates and |
JV Nakilat's contribution should have really gone up. So, where is that reduction coming from | |
year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter? | |
Akram Iswaisi: | It's just an accounting adjustment. |
Mustafa Aamer: | Sorry? |
Akram Iswaisi: | An accounting adjustment. |
Mustafa Aamer: | For Nakilat? |
Akram Iswaisi: | Yes. That's right. |
Mustafa Aamer: | All right. Okay. Could you elaborate on that? I'm not sure because... |
- 4 -
Akram Iswaisi: | Let me, you know year-end there are...we closed the books sometimes based on estimates due |
to timing and some adjustments are immaterial. So, if it's immaterial, we close the books to be | |
able to meet the deadlines, so it's simply an accounting adjustment. | |
Mustafa Aamer: | Right. All right. |
Akram Iswaisi: | Thank you. |
Operator: | Your next question comes from the line of Nikhil Phutane of CBFS. Your line is open. |
Nikhil Phutane: | Hi, good afternoon gentlemen, Akram, Sami. Thanks for the presentation. Well, you did |
mention in your previous answers that you're looking in terms of better performance, and | |
especially the first quarter was quite in good measure or wonderful performance, but I would | |
slightly like to defer on this. Actually, on your revenues, overall have come down and largely | |
on your...you name it, your bunker sales have come down, your Qatar quarries revenues have | |
come down, and as you mentioned rightly your container shipping has come down. And what | |
is more important somehow, you've managed to do your operating profit better margin because | |
of other operating expenses and operating...I mean so many other operating expenses which | |
have come down quite significantly as compared to the overall revenues. So, wanted to | |
understand what makes you think that the second quarter, the third quarter is going to be looking | |
much better? Thank you. | |
Akram Iswaisi: | Thank you for the question. And I agree with you. Revenue has come down, but our big focus |
right now is on profitable growth. We've had contracts in the past that had slim margins and | |
so what we've done is really focused on number one, for example, in some of the business | |
segments, increasing uptime. And increasing uptime again results in additional bottom-line | |
contributions, pure profit, reducing penalties in our operations wherever possible. Again, we | |
need to grow, but we need profitable growth. So, growth for the hell of growth doesn't make | |
sense if you're not able to generate margin and this is very much what we're focused on. We | |
can add another QR 500 million top line at 2% net profit, but that doesn't move much on the | |
bottom line. | |
So, a big focus of this company now is improving margins, which are key to our bottom-line | |
contribution and effectively, liquidity as well. This what you're seeing right now is our efforts | |
to continue to squeeze more out of our existing contracts and to be able to grow the business | |
profitably. | |
Now after that, there's a significant amount of activity and you guys are in the market, and you | |
know that, and that in the oil and gas sector. So, we have a pipeline of projects and opportunities | |
in Qatar that we're looking at and we're all quite optimistic that we can continue to deliver for | |
the rest of the year. | |
Nikhil Phutane: | Well, I think partly to a certain extent one can understand in terms of you're looking at oil and |
gas, which is very robust right now. But my understanding is, let us assume your offshore for | |
example, your operating expenses overall has come and reduced quite considerably as again the | |
run rate in the past. Similarly, that goes to a certain extent in your gas and petrochem business | |
also. So, I just wanted to know whether…will that be maintained in the sense that most likely | |
your revenues could be flat for the second quarter but margins also whatever we are seeing in | |
the first quarter will be maintained overall? |
- 5 -
Attachments
- Original Link
- Original Document
- Permalink
Disclaimer
Qatar Navigation QSC published this content on 30 April 2023 and is solely responsible for the information contained therein. Distributed by Public, unedited and unaltered, on 30 April 2023 05:47:07 UTC.