Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

4-Traders Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nyse  >  Prudential Financial Inc    PRU

Delayed Quote. Delayed  - 10/25 10:02:16 pm
82.89 USD   -0.78%
10/24DJU.S. Oversight of MetLife Called Into Question at Court Hearing
10/24 PRUDENTIAL FINA : Caroline Feeney receives NAFE Women of Excellence ..
10/24 U.S. government, MetLife set for rematch over 'too big to fail'
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsSector news 
The feature you requested does not exist. However, we suggest the following feature:

U.S. Oversight of MetLife Called Into Question at Court Hearing

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
10/24/2016 | 06:12pm CEST

WASHINGTON-U.S. oversight of MetLife Inc. was called into question Monday at a court hearing where the Obama administration sought to reassert the federal government's authority to regulate the large insurance firm.

Judges at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit asked pointed questions to government lawyers and at times appeared to express sympathy for MetLife during a hearing that lasted more than an hour.

But the three-judge panel pushed back on some of MetLife's arguments as well, and didn't clearly indicate its direction for a final decision. It could take months before the panel issues an opinion.

The Financial Stability Oversight Council, a group of senior regulators known as FSOC, is appealing to the court to reassert federal oversight of MetLife. It voted in December 2014 that the company was a "systemically important financial institution" deserving of stricter regulation, but U.S. District Judge Rosemary Collyer earlier this year overruled that decision, saying it was unreasonable and based on a "fatally flawed" process.

Judge Collyer was appointed by President George W. Bush.

The panel hearing Monday's arguments included two appointees of President Barack Obama, Judges Sri Srinivasan and Patricia Millett, as well as Judge A. Raymond Randolph, an appointee of President George H.W. Bush.

Beyond issues related to MetLife directly, the case holds broader significance.

The ability to bring large financial companies such as MetLife under tougher rules was an important piece of the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial overhaul. The law created the council to watch for gaps in financial regulation and to tag financial companies for stricter oversight if it determined their failure could put the broader economy at risk.

Judge Collyer's decision, if upheld, would call into question other instances where the Obama administration has used that authority, especially in the cases of American International Group Inc. and Prudential Financial Inc.

The Obama administration is also trying to protect the legacy of Dodd-Frank. The law has faced other legal challenges as well, including a recent ruling finding the structure of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau unconstitutional.

During Monday's hearing, Judges Millett and Srinivasan interrupted Mark Stern, an appellate litigation counsel at the Justice Department, several times to ask how his arguments were supported in public statements the FSOC has made. The judges could rule in MetLife's favor if they decide the regulators didn't adequately explain their procedures or reasoning.

Judge Millett, when discussing MetLife's contention that the FSOC hadn't adequately supported its conclusions, said part of the company's argument seemed "reasonable enough."

"You can't just say [MetLife] is so big" that if it fails, bad things will happen, she told Mr. Stern. "You're not specific enough when you say, 'It's a really, really bad situation? so we assume that bad things are going to happen.'"

Mr. Stern said the FSOC did extensive analysis to support its decision.

Lawyers for MetLife and the government also clashed on the question of whether the oversight council should have analyzed the likelihood that MetLife would find itself in deep economic distress.

Judge Randolph said the FSOC, by assuming MetLife was in trouble and then assessing the consequences, essentially predicted "there was a 100% chance" MetLife would fail.

Mr. Stern said the FSOC had a responsibility to assume the worst because financial crises, by their nature, are unexpected. He pointed to distress at AIG in the lead-up to the 2008 crisis: Probably the only people that would have predicted AIG's collapse, he said, "were the guys in 'The Big Short'," the book and movie about the handful of investors who foresaw the housing crash.

Eugene Scalia, partner at Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP representing MetLife, said there was no "explicit statutory compulsion" for the FSOC to assess the probability that MetLife would fail, but it is still unreasonable for the government to punish the company without analyzing that question.

Mr. Scalia also faced some pushback from the judges. Judge Millett disputed his characterization of part of the FSOC analysis, saying it was "much more comprehensive" than the MetLife lawyer was suggesting.

Judge Srinivasan told Mr. Scalia that Congress gave the FSOC flexibility, so perhaps the group wasn't "out of bounds" for ignoring some of the issues raised by MetLife.

Mr. Scalia said the FSOC violated the legal requirements that govern how federal agencies must make decisions, for example by ignoring expertise offered by insurance experts and not analyzing the impact its decision would have on MetLife.

Write to Ryan Tracy at ryan.tracy@wsj.com

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
10/24DJU.S. Oversight of MetLife Called Into Question at Court Hearing
10/24 PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL : Caroline Feeney receives NAFE Women of Excellence Award
10/24 U.S. government, MetLife set for rematch over 'too big to fail'
10/20 DEADLINE UPCOMING IN $33 MILLION SET : PRU) Investor Lawsuit
10/19 LANDAUER : First Trust Advisors Lp Decides to Keep It Stake in Landauer Inc. to ..
10/19 PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL : Investments continues to lower fees for multiple mutual f..
10/19 PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL : releases annual sustainability report
10/19 PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL : to offer Student loan assistance to campus hires
10/18 PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL INC : Regulation FD Disclosure (form 8-K)
10/18 Swiss National Bank Cuts its Investment of Stake in Iconix Brand Group Inc.
More news
Sector news : Life & Health Insurance - NEC
08:16pDJMANULIFE FINANCIAL : Loonie Jolts After Bank of Canada Governor's 'Wait' Comment
11:49a ST JAMES PLACE : Wealth manager St James's Place sees asset boost after Brexit v..
08:48aDJMETLIFE : Finance Watch -- WSJ
04:25aDJKyushu Railway Chugs Ahead in Debut Trading
10/24DJMETLIFE : U.S. Oversight of MetLife Called Into Question at Court Hearing
More sector news : Life & Health Insurance - NEC
News from SeekingAlpha
10/19 Explaining MTBC's Acquisition Of MediGain
10/18 Prudential downgraded ahead of earnings
10/17 DIVIDEND CHALLENGERS (AND NEAR-CHALL : 77 Increases Expected By The End Of Decem..
10/07 October 2016's Best 5 Large Cap CCC Stocks In Each Market Sector
10/07 Voya Financial a Top Pick as Credit Suisse initiates coverage of insurers
Financials ($)
Sales 2016 46 315 M
EBIT 2016 4 865 M
Net income 2016 4 299 M
Debt 2016 -
Yield 2016 3,38%
P/E ratio 2016 8,48
P/E ratio 2017 8,36
Capi. / Sales 2016 0,79x
Capi. / Sales 2017 0,76x
Capitalization 36 507 M
More Financials
Duration : Period :
Prudential Financial Inc Technical Analysis Chart | PRU | US7443201022 | 4-Traders
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends PRUDENTIAL FINANC...
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Technical analysis
Income Statement Evolution
More Financials
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 18
Average target price 86,8 $
Spread / Average Target 3,9%
Consensus details
EPS Revisions
More Estimates Revisions
John Robert Strangfeld Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Stephen P. Pelletier Chief Operating Officer-US Business & Executive VP
Charlie F. Lowrey Chief Operating Officer-International & EVP
Robert M. Falzon Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
Barbara G. Koster Chief Information Officer & Senior Vice President
More about the company
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
AXA-18.57%54 966
METLIFE INC-3.26%51 251
PRUDENTIAL PLC-8.69%44 183
More Results